Likes: 
Faceplams: Why weren't the The Fragile, La Mer, and No, You Don't Versions included on Things Falling Apart? The albums only 10 songs, they couldn't fit in 3 more? Or were those done after TFA was already completed/released?
Active Member
Why weren't the The Fragile, La Mer, and No, You Don't Versions included on Things Falling Apart? The albums only 10 songs, they couldn't fit in 3 more? Or were those done after TFA was already completed/released?
Throbbing Member
Pretty sure they were done before TFA. No idea why they weren't on there other than maybe they wanted all new stuff for the release, and those were already "out there" on the site.
Administrator
It's not the only video of course. AVOTT has been used this way at every show that they used screens that year (to fill the time when they change the gear on stage), so it's available on pretty much every full-length video source as well (from the top of my head - Moscow, St Petersburg, Bologna, there are probably more). It's just that there's not much to film in the darkness and therefore not many separate clips of it floating around.Originally Posted by dariocotti
Throbbing Member
I've always wondered that myself. At first I thought it could've been Peter Christopherson since they worked a lot together during that time and I know that Peter did some visuals for the first few Fragility shows (before they started to use Bill Viola's videos).
It turns out though that it's Simon Maxwell. He's credited in the Closure credits as director and editor for Hurt and Eraser, and nin's official youtube channel credits Maxwell on both of those videos as well. Not sure about TDS visuals since they only show short clips of that projection.
Strangely, his IMDB page even says that he did Wish, but that was in fact Peter Christopherson.
Administrator
He did Wish live, that's also on Closure
Hairy Member
Hi,
Does anyone experiencing an issue to d/l the album (from nin's site)?
24.24.2.2286
[I moved this]
Last edited by Sesquipedalism; 09-10-2013 at 11:14 PM.
Active Member
According to ninwiki, the vinyl sides are a, b, c etc so it looks like Trent is just being biased toward Americans. Maybe because he's afraid of them.
That was a very interesting question though.
Hairy Member
Thinking of covering Hesitation Marks, mainly piano cover, anyone think a transcription to piano would be good (sound wise) or be interested?
bastard from blue city
those credits are for the actual videos on Closure, not for the screen projections.
Stubby Member
Im looking for the seed 6 ninja tour ep, where the with teeth bsides are, anyone know where can I find it? I searched torrents and are all dead
she/her/hers
i have just the NIN tracks from it in 320kbps (i believe)
Josh Wink was on HLAH
http://www.portraitofdecay.com/dl.ni....y=29&submit=1
Stubby Member
yep, I went there , thanks, but the torrents are all dead and I wanted the .wav to burn a cd, but anyway Thank you!!
Administrator
Bottom of the page here:
http://www.seven1963.org/NINAudio.htm
Throbbing Member
Hmm, I guess you might be right. I wonder then if it could have been Peter Christopherson after all.
she/her/hers
i wouldn't be surprised. given all of the work he did for the in-between segments on closure, it seems reasonable that he could/would have assembled the hurt background footage.
Throbbing Member
It would make sense.
It would also make sense for NIN to include the name of the editor/director of the footage on their official youtube page for the Hurt and Eraser live videos. Right now it only credits Simon Maxwell.
Last edited by hobochic; 09-11-2013 at 05:30 PM.
Stubby Member
Thanks a lot for your reply! you guys are great!
Active Member
Well, the stuff from the "Eraser/Hurt/TDS" projections is stock footage so it's probably more of a question of who edited it, rather than who directed it. That could have been just about anyone. I know that only makes things murkier, but I thought I'd put that out there just so that we know we're not necessarily looking for a director.
Throbbing Member
True. The project still had to have some art direction, which most probably came from Trent, and/or Peter C, aside from editing though. Together those three clips are still some of my favorite live NIN moments, even more powerful than the high tech stuff they're touring with today. Can't say I'm not dying to see this upcoming tour though.
Throbbing Member
**thanks for the response!
Can anyone direct or send me a link to download "10 Miles High," "The New Flesh," and "Please (+Appendage)?"
please...
Last edited by captainbeyond; 09-12-2013 at 01:59 AM.
she/her/hers
check your PMs
Stubby Member
so as some of you may know Im collecting the seeds, and thank to some of you I already have 2 to 7, now Im looking for the seed 01 nin colected in .iso format, as it was a free dvd I dont think is ilegal to ask for that, isn it?
Josh Wink was on HLAH
I mean, if you're collecting them, why not go for an original? They're still pretty cheap
Active Member
This may be a long strecht but it has to be out there:
In 2005 I was skimming through the internet looking for music videos in mov or mp4 format. I stumbled upon a portfolio trailer by a director/animator etc. (I don't know anymore) which featured bits and pieces of several live documentaries and music videos. There was footage of a scraped QOTSA DVD from the songs for the deaf tour as well as some NIN among other artists I can't recall right now.
Does anyone know what I'm talking about? It's long ago and I can see it in front of my eyes but can't seem to find it anymore.
Stubby Member
oh! I didnt knew that seed 01 was in sale
Hairy Member
Does anyone have a list of the live videos NIN have uploaded? First ones I remember were Great Destroyer and Me, I'm Not from Year Zero and then there seemed to be alot after the 1,000,000 at Red Rocks. Thank You.
Administrator
http://www.echoingthesound.org/commu...2009-HD-Videos
Hairy Member
In the 2013 rehearsals that leaked, where does TR say something about 'faking playing something' during a certain song? I read about it somewhere here but listened to it but couldnt find it
Reply With Quote
