NIN songs you haven't seen live (but want to)

[hellabryanstyle]

I was going through the catalog just now and making a list of all the songs I haven't seen live and which ones I'd actually care to see; I'm curious about the rest of your experiences and opinions of which NIN songs you've never seen that you'd like to. Here's mine:

PHM

Kinda I Want To (don't want)
That's What I Get (don't want)
The Only Time (want)
Ringfinger (want a lot)

Broken

Happiness in Slavery (want)

TDS

I was lucky enough to be at the Palladium show

TF (left)

We're in This Together (want)

TF (right)

Where is Everybody? (want a lot - never played I believe)
I'm Looking Forward to Joining You, Finally (don't care, never played I believe)
Underneath it All (want the most of any I haven't seen, also never played I believe)
Ripe with Decay (less than don't want, negative amounts of wanting, never played)

WT

Sunspots (neutral, never played? I believe it was at least soundchecked at some point and I think some spiral members saw it.)

From Year Zero forward things start to get a little fuzzy. The only way I haven't seen these songs live is if they've never been played before I'm pretty sure, as I've been following the band extensively since '05. It would be pretty rad if Trent peppered in some more Ghosts tracks here and there. I really enjoyed the Ghosts portion of the Lights in the Sky tour.

Let me know if I'm incorrect about any of the songs that have never been played, and also if you happen to know off the top of your head which songs from YZ forward have never been played I'd be interested to know.

Edit: Ha, just saw Ryan's thread halfway down the page, so nevermind on that last part. No more guesswork required. :P

[Ryan]

Are we talking about songs that have both been played live and have not? If so, here are mine (a mix of both and I'll limit it to 15) -

1) Happiness In Slavery
2) Demon Seed
3) Into The Void
4) 10 Miles High
5) Somewhat Damaged
6) We're In This Together
7) Zero-Sum
8) Lights In The Sky
9) Metal
10) Sunspots

What I'd mainly like to see from Hesitation Marks in 2014:

11) Everything
12) I Would For You
13) In Two
14) Various Methods Of Escape
15) All Time Low


What I have seen -

Quick Stats
Total Shows Attended	7
Total Unique Songs Seen Performed	54
Total Songs Seen Performed	159

http://www.nintourhistory.com/profile.php?userid=1386

LISTEN	REMOVE
	2009-02-24	Hordern Pavilion	Australia Tour	Sydney	--	Australia	X
	2009-02-22	Eastern Creek Raceway	Australia Tour	Sydney	--	Australia	X
	2007-09-16	Hordern Pavilion	Summer / Fall Tour	Sydney	--	Australia	X
	2007-09-15	Big Top in Luna Park	Summer / Fall Tour	Sydney	--	Australia	X
	2007-05-09	Big Top in Luna Park	Australia / Japan Spring Tour	Sydney	--	Australia	X
	2005-08-20	Hordern Pavilion	With Teeth International Tour	Sydney	--	Australia	X
	2005-08-19	Hordern Pavilion	With Teeth International Tour	Sydney	--	Australia	X

Le seen:

SONGS SEEN PERFORMED
1,000,000	2
999,999	1
Beside You In Time (Intro)	1
Burn	6
Closer	5
Dead Souls	4
Discipline	1
Down In It	1
Eraser	2
Even Deeper	1
Gave Up	7
Head Down	1
Head Like A Hole	7
Help Me I Am In Hell	1
Heresy	2
Home	1
Hurt	6
Hyperpower!	3
La Mer	3
Last	1
Letting You	2
Love Is Not Enough	1
March of the Pigs	7
Me, I'm Not	3
Meet Your Master	1
Mr. Self Destruct	1
No, You Don't	4
Non-Entity	2
Only	3
Piggy	2
Pinion	1
Reptile	5
Ruiner	1
Sin	3
Something I Can Never Have	4
Starfuckers, Inc.	2
Suck	5
Survivalism	5
Terrible Lie	4
The Beginning Of The End	3
The Big Come Down	1
The Collector	1
The Day The World Went Away	2
The Downward Spiral	2
The Fragile	2
The Frail	4
The Good Soldier	5
The Great Destroyer	2
The Hand That Feeds	7
The Line Begins To Blur	3
The Wretched	4
Wish	7
With Teeth	2
You Know What You Are?	2

[Ryan]

Edited to include what I would like to see from HM.

[ethan829]

I would have loved to see Everything on the Tension tour.

[martin_b]

PHM:

Sanctified
Something I Can Never Have
* SIN *
Ringfinger

Broken:

* Last, Last, Last, Last... LAST! *
Happiness In Slavery
* PHYSICAL *
Suck

TDS:

Piggy
* HERESY *
Closer (yeah... I know)
* RUINER *
A Warm Place

TF:

The Frail/The Wretched
Just Like You Imagined
Into The Void
Where Is Everybody?
* THE MARK HAS BEEN MADE *
The Big Come Down
10 Miles High

AATCHB:

And All That Could Have Been
Leaving Hope

WT:

All The Love In The World
* THE LINE BEGINS TO BLUR *

YZ:

* VESSEL *
Me, I'm Not
The Warning
* MEET YOUR MASTER *
In This Twilight

The Slip:

NONE

HM:

* COPY OF A *
All Time Low
* VARIOUS METHODS OF ESCAPE *
* IN TWO *
While I'm Still Here
Black Noise

PS. BTW: great thread. :-)

[Ryan]

Oh yeah, how could I leave off Just Like You imagined?!

[hani]

never been to a NIN show, so I'll just list what I really wanna see live:

PHM:

HLAH (obviously)
Terrible Lie (also obviously)
Sanctified
Kinda I Want To
The Only Time

Broken:

Wish
Last
Happiness In Slavery (DUH)
Suck

TDS:
Mr. Self Destruct
Piggy
Heresy
The Becoming
A Warm Place
Reptile
Burn

TF:

Somewhat Damaged
The Frail/The Wretched
We're In This Together
Even Deeper
Pilgrimage
No, You Don't
The Way Out Is Through
Into The Void
Please
I'm Looking Forward to Joining You, Finally
The Big Come Down
Underneath It All

WT:

All The Love In The World
The Collector
With Teeth
Getting Smaller
Sunspots (PLEASE GOD PLEASE)
The Line Begins To Blur
Beside You In Time

YZ:

Vessel
Me, I'm Not
The Warning
God Given
The Great Destroyer
In This Twilight
Zero-Sum

TS:

1,000,000
Echoplex
Head Down
The Four Of Us Are Dying
Demon Seed

HM:

Copy of A
All Time Low
Dissapointed
Running
In Two
While I'm Still Here/Black Noise

it's highly impossible to ever see all of them, but come on, a man can dream, righ

[theimage13]

All songs that have not been played live before.

[ryanmcfly]

I'm going to keep it within reason, as in stuff that's been played since the With Teeth era.
PHM:
Down In It
Something I Can Never Have

Broken:
Suck
Last

The Downward Spiral:
Ruiner
Eraser
Reptile

The Fragile:
The Day the World Went Away
The Big Come Down
We're in this Together

With Teeth:
All the Love in the world
Love is Not Enough
Getting Smaller
The Line Begins to Blur
Right Where it Belongs

Year Zero:
God Given
Meet Your Master
Vessel
The Great Destroyer

The Slip:
Discipline
Head Down

Hesitation Marks:
Various Methods of Escape
I Would For You.

[sick among the pure]

For the most part, when it comes to songs that have been played recently-enough to be reasonable, but I have not seen, my list is pretty much "the more Fragile, the better. And The Great Destroyer." I was lucky enough to catch all of HM (minus Everything, obviously) between Made in America and my Tension shows.

[GavinCollins420]

Closer and Hurt.
Fuck me, right?

[Volband]

I'll only list those songs I'd really really really REAAALLLY would like to see and hear live, since I've been at only 1 show, so the real list would be too big.

PHM:
- Terrible Lie (plsplsplsplsPLS)
- Sin

Broken:
- Happiness In Slavery

TDS:
- Ruiner

TF(-era):
- The Perfect Drug
- The Fragile
- Starfuckers Inc.
- Even Deeper
- We're In This Together
- Where Is Everybody?
- Into The Void (not the new, softpussy version though, that's lame)
- And All That Could Have Been

With Teeth:
- All The Love In The World
- You Know What You Are?
- The Line Begins To Blur
- Sunspots

Year Zero:
- The Warning
- The Great Destroyer
- God Given
- In This Twilight

Ghosts:
- 8

The Slip:
- Head Down

Hesitation Marks:
- Copy Of A
- Came Back Haunted
- All Time Low
- Satellite
- Various Methods Of Escape

[icklekitty]

I don't know, when I think of my favourite NIN songs I've pretty much heard them all, including a lot of the stuff listed above.
Looking forward to hearing more of HM live next year.
JLYI would be nice.
Perhaps some of the now deemed "cheesy" stuff from PHM.

[Halo Infinity]

Pretty Hate Machine
Kinda I Want To
That's What I Get
The Only Time
Ringfinger

Broken
Last
Happiness In Slavery
Physical (You're So)

The Downward Spiral
Mr Self Destruct
Ruiner
Big Man With A Gun

The Fragile (Left)
We're In This Together
Just Like You Imagined
Pilgrimage
No, You Don't
La Mer
The Great Below

The Fragile (Right)
The Way Out Is Through
Into The Void
Where Is Everybody?
The Mark Has Been Made
I'm Looking Forward To Joining You, Finally
The Big Come Down
Ripe (With Decay)

And All That Could Have Been (Still)
Adrift And At Peace
Gone, Still
Leaving Hope

With Teeth
All The Love In The World
Every Day Is Exactly The Same
Getting Smaller
Sunspots
Home

Year Zero
Hyperpower!
The Beginning Of The End
The Good Soldier
Vessel
Capital G
My Violent Heart
God Given
Meet Your Master
The Great Destroyer
In This Twilight
Zero-Sum

Ghosts I-II
10 - Ghosts II
11 - Ghosts II
12 - Ghosts II
14 - Ghosts II
18 - Ghosts II

Ghosts III-IV
19 - Ghosts III
24 - Ghosts III
29 - Ghosts IV
34 - Ghosts IV

The Slip
Letting You
Discipline
Head Down
Lights In The Sky
The Four Of Us Are Dying
Demon Seed

Hesitation Marks
The Eater Of Dreams
Everything
Various Methods Of Escape
I Would For You

Non-Album Songs
Now I'm Nothing
The Perfect Drug (Yes, I know. I wish.)
Driver Down
Deep
Non-Entity

The MTV Japan song into or out of the Tetsuo: The Bullet Man Theme (Which would most likely never happen either, but I've also wondered how that would've turned out several times before.)

[head_lice]

If only I had my fake Id at 14. Some old ones.

"Twist" and "Sex Dwarf"

Dont think he played "Supernaught" live but that would have been awesome.

[sick among the pure]

Closer and Hurt.
Fuck me, right?

Wait, how does this happen? What show(s) have you been to where neither was played?

[Zipfinator]

I would love to see The Frail/The Wretched. At the Aragon 8/29 show they played The Frail and I was super excited for The Wretched. They went right into I Do Not Want This though...

[sick among the pure]

I would love to see The Frail/The Wretched. At the Aragon 8/29 show they played The Frail and I was super excited for The Wretched. They went right into I Do Not Want This though...

Night one had Frail/Wretched, and it was my first time. I almost died from joy.

[GavinCollins420]

Wait, how does this happen? What show(s) have you been to where neither was played?

Leeds festival in August.

http://www.setlist.fm/setlist/nine-i...-33c60c6d.html

[packetslave]

I would love to see The Frail/The Wretched. At the Aragon 8/29 show they played The Frail and I was super excited for The Wretched. They went right into I Do Not Want This though...

To be fair, though, we got "Right Where it Belongs v2", which was glorious.

[hellabryanstyle]

JLYI would be nice.

I could have sworn I saw you in line at the Fonda show in LA. If you were there, it was played at that show.

[icecream]

Realistically:
PHM: Down in it, Something I can Never Have, Sin,
TDS: Reptile, Burn
TF: TDTWWA, La Mer, Into the Void
HM: In Two

Unlikely:
PHM: The Only Time
Broken: Last, Happiness in Slavery
TDS: Mr.Self Destruct, Heresy, The Becoming, Eraser
TF: We're in this Together, The Fragile, Just Like You Imagined, The Way Out is Through, The Great Below
WT: Love is Not Enough, The Line Begins to Blur, Besides you in Time, Right Where it Belongs, Home
YZ: The Great Destroyer
TS: The Lights in the Sky
HM: Everything, The Eater of Dreams, I Would for You

[Halo Infinity]

Wait, how does this happen? What show(s) have you been to where neither was played?

Something like that has happened to me before as well. I only got to see Closer live once in my life. I only saw NIN 3 times though, and Hurt was performed in all three of them, but Closer wasn't played on the last 2 NIN concerts I've attended, at both the Jones Beach Theater in Wantagh, NY and Barclays Center at Brooklyn, NY. It was at least performed at the Madison Square Garden in New York, NY though.

If I ever see Closer live again, I'd hope to actually see it performed without the part from The Only Time put into it.

[R-Dot-Yung]

I was very lucky to see Meet Your Master,

But every show I go to I'm always hoping it comes out because that track is just the tits.

[sick among the pure]

Something like that has happened to me before as well. I only got to see Closer live once in my life. I only saw NIN 3 times though, and Hurt was performed in all three of them, but Closer wasn't played on the last 2 NIN concerts I've attended, at both the Jones Beach Theater in Wantagh, NY and Barclays Center at Brooklyn, NY. It was at least performed at the Madison Square Garden in New York, NY though.

If I ever see Closer live again, I'd hope to actually see it performed without the part from The Only Time put into it.

Probably won't happen, they even left that in for the TDS shows.

[icklekitty]

I could have sworn I saw you in line at the Fonda show in LA. If you were there, it was played at that show.

Sometimes I queue for shows but don't actually go inside. I'm a troll like that.

[snaapz]

demon seed

[Tumnayar]

Closer to god should replace closer permanently if he adds closer back to the setlists, always been a big fan of that song.

[henryeatscereal]

I would kill to listen to "Right Were it belongs" live...

[screwdriver]

I'd still rank The Fragile my "favorite" album although it's been years since I've listened to it -- I just listened to it NONstop for years so I'm a bit bored with it ;-)

nonetheless, seeing The Wretched, Even Deeper, Somewhat Damaged, TDTWWA at the last show I was at and just... being blown away again by those tunes... my fantasies again turn towards seeing the whole album live. There's not an audience for that, I don't think, but god that would make me so happy.