The Loop Closes (video)

[BRoswell]

Yes, they're the visuals from the opening credits, but who's to say that Fincher didn't "direct" where the focus should be? Remember, the video features closely cropped visuals from the credits. It's not that unlikely that Fincher guided the people in charge of making the video. Sure, he may not have directed it in the traditional sense, but who cares?

[my voice just]

sure he guided: ‘CG, very adult, super dark, leather, skin, blood, snow, breasts, vaginas, needles, piercings, motorcycles, vengeance.’ (c)

but the music video isn`t just cropped, it`s cropped, alternatively edited and CRT-effected


so, you assert that music video was too made by the same people and under fincher`s guidance, only because it`s so like the opening sequence and pitchfork said so?

[BRoswell]

but the music video isn`t just cropped, it`s cropped, alternatively edited and CRT-effected


so, you assert that music video was too made by the same people and under fincher`s guidance, only because it`s so like the opening sequence and pitchfork said so?

No, I'm saying that because he's credited with directing it. I don't see any reason for them to hide the fact that someone else did it.

[eversonpoe]

sure he guided: ‘CG, very adult, super dark, leather, skin, blood, snow, breasts, vaginas, needles, piercings, motorcycles, vengeance.’ (c)

but the music video isn`t just cropped, it`s cropped, alternatively edited and CRT-effected


so, you assert that music video was too made by the same people and under fincher`s guidance, only because it`s so like the opening sequence and pitchfork said so?

No, I'm saying that because he's credited with directing it. I don't see any reason for them to hide the fact that someone else did it.

it's like when someone directs a movie...other people still work on it doing various things, but the director is still the director.

[BRoswell]

it's like when someone directs a movie...other people still work on it doing various things, but the director is still the director.

Exactly. I'm not saying Fincher did the whole thing by himself, but he technically directed it and is created as doing so. End of story.

[my voice just]

No, I'm saying that because he's credited with directing it.

where i can see him credited with directing it?

[botley]

Oh, hey there ppl arguing over who did what on the video this thread is NOT about, why don't you go take a brisk walk outside for a bit?