The Loop Closes (video)

[my voice just]

i think this work of [mostly] rob is inspired by this [partly] work of trent:


and that creepy "the ring" video cassete, of course

[eversonpoe]

i think this work of [mostly] rob is inspired by this [partly] work of trent:

well, that video was directed by david fincher, right? as it's basically the opening credits of the film?

[my voice just]

i guess ninwiki (and pitchfork) are spreading a little misinformation about this

in one of post-realease girl with a dragon tattoo fincher interviews he said (about trent) something like "he was very enthusiastic to do that music video" or something like that. unfortunately, i couldn`t find the proof link, but it engrained in my memory

the truth is - fincher didn`t directed opening credits for the film. there`s specially trained people for that

and if you turn the logic on taking into account all the above, fincher`s presumably being busy with the film realease and the CRT effect, i think it`s pretty obvious, that it`s not fincher, who`s responsible for immigrant`s song video

[jessamineny]

i guess ninwiki (and pitchfork) are spreading a little misinformation about this

in one of post-realease girl with a dragon tattoo fincher interviews he said (about trent) something like "he was very enthusiastic to do that music video" or something like that. unfortunately, i couldn`t find the proof link, but it engrained in my memory

the truth is - fincher didn`t directed opening credits for the film. there`s specially trained people for that

and if you turn the logic on taking into account all the above, fincher`s presumably being busy with the film realease and the CRT effect, i think it`s pretty obvious, that it`s not fincher, who`s responsible for immigrant`s song video

So if there are specially trained people for that and you turn the logic on... what makes you think Trent Reznor would even partly be responsible for creating the visuals for the opening of a $90 million Hollywood film? Isn't it more logical that, even if Fincher did use the words "music video," that he just meant the music? If I remember correctly, Fincher made a special request for the cover of this song specifically for the opening sequence.

[my voice just]

what makes you think Trent Reznor would even partly be responsible for creating the visuals for the opening of a $90 million Hollywood film?

where i`d say that?

you`re confusing visuals for the opening with music video, which are not the same, if you look closely enough