Warning: This is a massive setlist. I imagined it as a special show for nin.com forum members, played at the Carnegie Hall.

1. Under The Midnight Sun
2. 3 Ghosts I
3. Dead Souls
4. The Becoming
5. All Time Low
6. Leaving Hope
7. Find My Way (Oneohtrix Point Never remix)
8. No, You Don't
9. Happiness In Slavery
10. The Line Begins To Blur
11. Disappointed
12. 10 Miles High
13. The Great Destroyer
14. Ruiner
15. The Day The World Went Away
16. 27 Ghosts III
17. Just Like You Imagined
18. The Hand That Feeds
19. Head Like A Hole
20. Terrible Lie
21. Down In It
22. Sanctified
23. Something I Can Never Have
24. Kinda I Want To
25. Sin
26. That's What I Get
27. The Only Time
28. Ringfinger
29. Metal
30. Hurt

Encore:

31. Corona Radiata
32. Copy Of A
33. Pieces Form The Whole
34. Burn

Encore 2:

35. I Would For You
36. We're In This Together

Encore 3:

37. Closer
38. The Great Below
39. Heresy
40. In This Twilight
41. Right Where It Belongs (V2)
42. And All That Could Have Been



Band lineup:

Trent Reznor: Lead vocals, guitar, keyboards
Adrian Belew: Lead guitar, backing vocals
Josh Eustis: Keyboards, misc, backing vocals
Alessandro Cortini: Keyboards, misc, backing vocals
Eric Avery: Bass
Ilan Rubin: Drums

(in other words, the band lineup that was announced when the comeback tour was announced.)

And before you complain about the lack of realism: let me point out that this would be just a one-off set (not a tour), several months before and/or after any other shows.