Faceplams Faceplams:  0
Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 1 2
Results 31 to 43 of 43

Thread: Tour Rarities Game

  1. #31
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Location
    London
    Posts
    1,968
    Mentioned
    49 Post(s)
    Quote Originally Posted by cdm View Post
    Two things: 1. NYC / Chicago / LA crowds
    Travel is a thing. I've only been to two shows in LA (three shows in the USA total) and I have one of the highest point scores so far.

    To your other point, the site also doesn't seem to differentiate between metal WITH Gary Numan and metal as NIN.
    Last edited by icklekitty; 12-18-2018 at 07:30 AM.

  2. #32
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Posts
    420
    Mentioned
    8 Post(s)
    I think these are right.

    160 She's Gone Away
    160 The Loop Closes* ( IM COUNTING IT GODDAMMIT )
    147 Strange Kind of Love*
    131 Digital*
    127 Parasite*
    124 Final Solution*
    117 In Two x2
    117 The Background World
    114 I Can't Give Everything Away*
    111 Please
    1425 Total

    Without Covers
    160 She's Gone Away
    117 In Two x2
    117 The Background World
    111 Please
    109 Over and Out
    107 This Isn't the Place
    104 Various Methods of Escape
    104 Perfect Drug x2
    102 All the Love In the World
    101 Just Like You Imagined
    1353 Total

    I can't believe I just spent time on this. This is ripe for some new code built into NIN Tour History.

  3. #33
    Join Date
    Feb 2013
    Posts
    6
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Awesome idea, and fun to calculate with nintourhistory and setlist.fm side by side:

    160. Beautiful People
    160. She's Gone Away
    147. 8 Ghosts I
    147. Strange Kind of Love
    147. Kick in the Eye
    131. Digital
    124. Final Solution
    121. Banged and Blown Through
    121. Lights in the Sky
    121. Meet Your Master
    TOTAL: 1379

    Without covers:
    160. She's Gone Away
    147. 8 Ghosts I
    121. Lights in the Sky (x2)
    121. Meet Your Master (x2)
    117. In Two (x2)
    111. 17 Ghosts II (x2)
    TOTAL: 1247

    Without covers and without counting songs twice:
    160. She's Gone Away
    147. 8 Ghosts I
    121. Lights in the Sky
    121. Meet Your Master
    117. In Two
    111. 17 Ghosts II
    111. Satellite
    109. Over and Out
    107. This Isnt The Place
    104. The Perfect Drug
    TOTAL: 1208

  4. #34
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Belarus
    Posts
    2,947
    Mentioned
    35 Post(s)
    99 Branches/Bones
    94 Gone, Still
    91 HYPERPOWER!
    88 Ahead of Ourselves
    84 Shit Mirror
    84 God Break Down the Door
    80 The Lovers
    77 Less Than
    70 The Way Out Is Through
    70 Last

    Total: 837
    Sigh.


    How about a different game?
    Similar rules, but you list top-10 most played songs that you haven't seen.

    9 Sin
    12 Down in It
    15 The Frail
    17 The Wretched
    22 Get Down, Make Love
    26 The Only Time
    28 Somewhat Damaged
    31 Ringfinger
    33 That's What I Get
    33 Starfuckers, Inc.

    total: 226

  5. #35
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Location
    London
    Posts
    1,968
    Mentioned
    49 Post(s)
    Quote Originally Posted by fillow View Post

    How about a different game?
    Similar rules, but you list top-10 most played songs that you haven't seen.

    9 Sin
    12 Down in It
    15 The Frail
    17 The Wretched
    22 Get Down, Make Love
    26 The Only Time
    28 Somewhat Damaged
    31 Ringfinger
    33 That's What I Get
    33 Starfuckers, Inc.

    total: 226
    Interesting! I'm surprised some of those are so high up.


    Here's mine:
    22 Get Down Make Love
    26 The Only Time
    31 Ringfinger
    33 That's What I Get
    38 Happiness in Slavery
    64 Right Where It Belongs
    68 31 Ghosts
    74 All Time Low
    78 The Mark Has Been Made
    79 Complication

    =513

    (I've apparently heard Down in it live 7 times? I have no recollection of this).
    Last edited by icklekitty; 12-19-2018 at 08:08 AM.

  6. #36
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Ontari-ari-ario
    Posts
    3,908
    Mentioned
    162 Post(s)
    Quote Originally Posted by fillow View Post
    How about a different game?
    Similar rules, but you list top-10 most played songs that you haven't seen.
    I got pretty lucky seeing a Fragility 2.0 show, and every tour since barring Performance 2007, so it's mostly old tracks (except for "Less Than" and "HYPERPOWER!") on my still-to-see list:

    26 The Only Time
    31 Ringfinger
    33 That's What I Get
    41 The Downward Spiral
    70 Last
    73 Physical (You're So)
    77 Less Than
    84 Big Man with a Gun
    88 Piggy (Nothing Can Stop Me Now)
    91 HYPERPOWER!

    total: 614

    Rounding out the top twenty:

    94 Gone, Still
    98 Deep
    99 Branches/Bones
    102 All the Love in the World
    102 Closer to God
    106 Getting Smaller
    107 This Isn't the Place
    109 Hand Covers Bruise
    109 Over and Out
    111 Satellite
    Last edited by botley; 12-19-2018 at 06:51 AM.

  7. #37
    Join Date
    Sep 2014
    Posts
    90
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Quote Originally Posted by fillow View Post
    How about a different game?
    Similar rules, but you list top-10 most played songs that you haven't seen.
    Agree that this is an interesting twist.

    My score is 652. Here is a breakdown, along with a comment about the frequency of being played and relative rarity.

    1 That's What I Get 33 pts Played 153 times, none since '91
    2 Me, I'm Not 42 112, (not that rare, just missed it!)
    3 No, You Don't 51 90, none since '07
    4 Into the Void 55 81, none since '13
    5 The Great Below 66 60, none since '00
    6 With Teeth 75 49, none since '07
    7 The Mark Has Been Made 78 44, none since '00
    8 Complication 78 44, none since '00
    9 Big Man With A Gun 84 41, only twice since '94
    10 The Collector 90 37, none since '09

    A "win" here could be LOWEST score, in which case you might be considered the UN-luckiest NIN fan; or the HIGHEST score, in which you would be glossed 'King/Queen of the Catalog.'

    If you're looking for high scores, it probably favors older fans, and more frequent attendance at shows. Obviously, the earlier in a band's career, the smaller the catalog, and the more frequent everything was played. The older material falls off over time, and becomes more 'rare,' even though the play count remains relatively high. Although, the diverse selists of the '09 and '18 runs also fill in some of the gaps.

  8. #38
    Join Date
    Feb 2013
    Posts
    6
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Quote Originally Posted by fillow View Post
    How about a different game?
    Similar rules, but you list top-10 most played songs that you haven't seen.
    Another awesome idea! Here are my 10:

    31. Ringfinger
    33. That’s What I Get
    51. No, You Don’t
    75. With Teeth
    81. Now Im Nothing
    91. HYPERPOWER
    99. Branches/Bones
    101. Just Like You Imagined
    102. Closer to God
    104. Various Methods of Escape

    ​TOTAL: 738
    Last edited by miked732; 07-29-2019 at 02:41 PM. Reason: Caught a mistake

  9. #39
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Montréal, Québec
    Posts
    330
    Mentioned
    7 Post(s)
    I don't think we should be counting multipliers. I'm seeing people here getting very high scores from mid-level rarities ranking at around 100 but seen a dozen time.

    Here's my count anyway, from 39 shows :

    WITH COVERS
    160 - She’s Gone Away
    160 - The Loop Closes
    134 - Subterraneans
    134 - AATCHB
    131 - Digital (2)
    127 - What If We Could
    127 - Parasite (2)
    127 - 6 Ghosts I
    124 - 14 Ghosts II
    124 - Final Solution


    Total : 1 353
    With multipliers : 1 611




    WITHOUT COVERS
    160 - She’s Gone Away
    134 - AATCHB
    127 - What If We Could
    127 - 6 Ghosts I
    124 - 14 Ghosts II
    121 - Lights In The Sky
    121 - Meet Your Master (3)
    119 - 28 Ghosts IV
    117 - In Two (2)
    117 - The Background World (4)

    Total : 1267
    With multipliers : 1977



    Songs not seen :

    26 - The Only Time
    31 - Ringfinger
    33 - That’s What I Get
    66 - The Great Below
    78 - The Mark Has Been Made
    78 - Complications
    84 - Big Man With A Gun
    91 - Hyperpower
    98 - Deep
    101 - Just Like You Imagined

    Total : 686

  10. #40
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    NYC
    Posts
    200
    Mentioned
    2 Post(s)
    Here's my never-seen top 20.

    Ignoring the Ghosts tracks and PHM favorites that haven't been played since the mid-90s, I'm still holding out hope of seeing GDML and at least a few of the Fragile and W_T-era rarities before Trent hangs up his spurs.

    Rank Points Song
    1 22 Get Down Make Love (Queen cover)
    2 26 The Only Time
    3 31 Ringfinger
    4 33 That's What I Get
    5 51 No, You Don't
    6 75 With Teeth
    7 91 HYPERPOWER!
    8 94 Every Day Is Exactly the Same
    9 98 Deep
    10 104 Various Methods of Escape
    11 107 21 Ghosts III
    12 109 Hand Covers Bruise (TR/AR cover)
    13 111 Please
    14 115 1 Ghosts I
    15 115 25 Ghosts III
    16 119 Maybe Just Once
    17 119 28 Ghosts IV
    18 121 Capital G
    19 124 14 Ghosts II
    20 127 Kinda I Want To
    Top 10 625
    Top 20 1,792

  11. #41
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Location
    MI
    Posts
    870
    Mentioned
    6 Post(s)
    Made super simple by my having no covers in my top 10 or songs heard more than once. That's what happens when you only see 1-2 shows a tour and when you started in 2000 lol

    147 - 8 Ghosts I

    121 - Meet Your Master
    117 - The Background World
    115 - 1 Ghosts I
    109 - Over and Out
    107 - 21 Ghosts III
    107 - This Isn't the Place
    104 - The Perfect Drug
    102 - All the Love in the World
    99 - Branches/Bones [Burning Bright (Field on Fire) also tied for this slot]
    1128 Total

  12. #42
    Join Date
    Jan 2017
    Location
    Chicago
    Posts
    508
    Mentioned
    12 Post(s)
    Rarest 10 I have seen (including doubles and covers...):
    134 - Subterraneans 27oct2018
    134 - AATCHB 26oct2018
    131 - Digital 16jun2018
    127 - Parasite 16jun2018
    117 - The Background World 15sep2017
    117 - The Background World 15jun2018
    114 - I can't give everything away 15sep2017
    114 - I can't give everything away 15jun2018
    114 - I can't give everything away 27oct2018
    109 - over and out 25oct2018
    Score 1211
    Top 10 most played havn't seen:
    10 suck
    12 down in it
    22 get down make love
    23 dead souls
    26 The Only time
    29 La Mer
    31 ringfinger
    33 that's what i get
    36 you know what you are
    37 The line begins to blur
    score 259

  13. #43
    Join Date
    Jan 2016
    Posts
    175
    Mentioned
    1 Post(s)
    I've only been to two concerts thus far, so my score is rather low 855 points:

    Rank Track Name Play Count Points Venue
    1 Digital* 6 131
    Zitadelle Berlin 2018
    2 Branches/Bones 25 99 Zitadelle Berlin 2018
    3 Ahead of Ourselves 38 88 Zitadelle Berlin 2018
    4 God Break Down the Door 41 84 Zitadelle Berlin 2018
    5 Shit Mirror 41 84 Zitadelle Berlin 2018
    6 The Lovers 43 80 Zitadelle Berlin 2018
    7 Less Than 45 77 Zitadelle Berlin 2018
    8 Metal* 46 76 Berlin Arena 2009
    9 Physical (You‘re So)* 55 73 Berlin Arena 2009
    10 I‘m Afraid of Americans* 70 63 Berlin Arena 2009

    I am quite happy I got to see Digital. Afraid of Americans I have seen twice, but as it is the last of the list it only counts one time.

    Without covers the score goes down to 731 points. These are the successors:

    Rank Track Name Play Count Points Venue
    6 Less Than 45 77 Zitadelle Berlin 2018
    7 Non-Entity 72 61 Berlin Arena 2009
    8 Heresy 72 61 Berlin Arena 2009
    9 Head Down 80 56 Berlin Arena 2009
    10 The Downward Spiral 117 41 Berlin Arena 2009

    Considering my top ten consists to great parts of trilogy songs I think that these are even cooler to some extend. I am especially glad I got to see Non-Entity and Heresy.

    In my top tracks there are still some major standards missing:

    Rank Track Name Play Count Points
    1 Terrible Lie 742 4
    2 Closer 617 7
    3 Sin 515 9
    4 Suck 480 10
    5 The Wretched 325 17
    6 Eraser 296 19
    7 Only 287 20
    8 Sanctified 287 20
    9 Get Down, Make Love 255 22
    10 Dead Souls 215 23

    My rank is 151 points. So apparently I'd be one of the persons that would be happy to see Closer. Terrible Lie is also a big miss. I am quite surprised to see Get Down, Make Love in this list though. Didn't know that it has been such a staple in NIN's performances
    Last edited by SchwarzerAbt; 12-21-2018 at 04:47 PM.

Posting Permissions