I forgot until just a few moments ago that yesterday morning while eating at Mr. Lucky's a guy from a table of four a few over from us came up to my wife and me and asked if we went to the Saturday show (I was wearing my NIN hat).
"Yeah! It was awesome!"
"Did they play Closer?"
"Yeah."
"FUCK."
"They also played The Perfect Drug and no song newer than 1997."
"We already saw the Perfect Drug. [to someone at the table] HEY. THEY PLAYED CLOSER."

And everyone else at the table got bummed as well.

Baffling.