Edit An Album

[neorev]

The Heavy Downward Spiral EP
01 Mr. Self Destruct
02 Piggy (Nothing Can Stop Me Now)
03 March Of The Pigs
04 Burn
05 Big Man With A Gun

The Art Of Self Destruction EP
01 Mr. Self Destruct
02 The Art Of Self Destruction, Part One
03 Self Destruction, Part 2
04 Self Destruction, Part 3
05 Self Destruction, Final

The The Fragile
01 The Frail
02 The Wretched
03 The Fragile
04 The Great Below
05 The Day The World Went Away (from WITT single)
06 The Way Out Is Through
07 The Mark Has Been Made
08 The Great Collapse
09 The New Flesh (from WITT single)
10 The Persistence Of Loss
11 The Perfect Drug (from WITT single)
12 The Big Comedown

The Year Zero EP
01 The Beginning Of The End
02 The Warning
03 The Good Soldier
04 The Great Destroyer
05 The Greater Good

I also had an alternate version...

The Year Zero GP (G-Rated Edition)
01 Capital G
02 The Good Soldier
03 The Great Destroyer
04 The Greater Good
05 God Given

Hesitation Marks Are Fun! EP (the funky dance side)
01 Copy Of A
02 Came Back Haunted
03 Satellite
04 Running
05 Everything

[totom]

Broken (from EP to single):
01 Wish
02 Gave Up

Maybe add Pinion and Help me I'm in Hell as intro for each side.


Hesitation Marks:
01. The Eater of Dreams
02. Copy of A
03. All Time Low
04. Various Methods of Escape
05. I Would for You
06. While I'm Still Here
07. Black Noise

[eversonpoe]

sorry, only 5 tracks isn't enough. i think an EP should be able to be 6 tracks.

With Teeth
1. all the love in the world
2. the collector
3. with teeth
4. only (El-P remix)
5. the line begins to blur
6. right where it belongs (v2)

The Downward Spiral
1. piggy (nothing can stop me now)
2. closer (precursor)
3. the becoming
4. i do not want this
5. eraser
6. the downward spiral (the bottom)

Broken
1. help me i'm in hell (into) happiness in slavery
2. suck

Pretty Hate Machine
1. terrible lie
2. sanctified (2013 version)
3. something i can never have (still version)
4. kinda i want to
5. sin (and all that could have been version)
6. the only time

i'll do the rest another time.

[Kulerage]

(Special thanks to Henrie_Schnee for this alt-universe style post)
Everyone has mixed feelings from this weird album titled "With Teeth". Seems to have come out in 2005, but the only NIN release I know of from that point in time was this EP titled "Bleed" where Trent experimented with several sounds. Here's the track listing for anyone that wants it

Bleed
1. All The Love In The World
2. The Hand That Feeds (Ruff Mix)
3. Only
4. The Line Begins To Blur
5. Right Where It Belongs

[Dryalex12]

The Fragile
The Day The World Went Away
The Frail
The Wretched
The Fragile
The Way Out Is Through
The New Flesh
The Mark Has Been Made
10 Miles High
Slipping Away
Somewhat Damaged
The Great Collapse
The Big Come Down
Underneath It All
The Second Half of TDTWWA (quiet version, the part leading up to the nana, as a reprise)
I'm Looking Looking Forward To Joining You, Finally
And All That Could Have Been
The Great Below

[Ryan]

I'd keep The Slip as it is except remove Letting You and have Demon Seed extended with the additional lyrics not sung actually sung.

[Ryan]

The Art Of Self Destruction EP
01 Mr. Self Destruct
02 The Art Of Self Destruction, Part One
03 Self Destruction, Part 2
04 Self Destruction, Part 3
05 Self Destruction, Final

+ the beauty of being numb

[neorev]

+ the beauty of being numb

Following the 5 EP track rule... plus I feel that track is quite different from the others and includes that Aphex Twin bit that's a bit out of place.

[seasonsinthesky]

Following the 5 EP track rule... plus I feel that track is quite different from the others and includes that Aphex Twin bit that's a bit out of place.

Just use section A, then. And it certainly fits better than SD Part 2, which is the exact same arrangement as the album version, with only a slightly altered mix (and no Belew noise-guitar ending).

[BRoswell]

Just realized I never did my own challenge, so here are my edits:

Pretty Hate Machine:
Head Like A Hole
Terrible Lie
Sin
Something I Can Never Have
Ringfinger


Head Like A Hole:
Head Like A Hole (Slate)
Terrible Lie (Sympathetic Mix)
You Know Who You Are
Down In It (Shred)
Let's Hear It For Nine Inch Nails!


Broken:
Help Me I Am In Hell
Happiness In Slavery
Gave Up


The Downward Spiral:
Mr. Self Destruct
Closer
A Warm Place
Eraser
Hurt


Further Down The Spiral:
Piggy (Nothing Can Stop Me Now)
Heresy (Version)
The Downward Spiral (The Bottom)
Eraser (Polite)
Ruiner (Version)


The Fragile:
The Day The World Went Away
The Frail
The Wretched
We're In This Together
Just Like You Imagined
La Mer
The Great Below
Into The Void
Ripe (With Decay)


Things Falling Apart:
Slipping Away
The Great Collapse
The Frail
Metal
Starfuckers, Inc. (Version 3)


With Teeth:
All The Love In The World
The Hand That Feeds
Only
Beside You In Time
Home


Year Zero:
Survivalism
Vessel
God Given
The Greater Good
In This Twilight


Year Zero Remixed:
The Great Destroyer (Modwheelmood Remix)
My Violent Heart (Pirate Robot Midget Remix)
Survivalism (Saul Williams Remix)
Another Version Of The Truth (Kronos Quartet and Enrique Gonzalez Muller Remix)
Zero-Sum (Stephen Morris and Gillian Gilbert Remix)


Ghosts:
1 Ghosts I
2 Ghosts I
7 Ghosts I
8 Ghosts I
9 Ghosts I
13 Ghosts II
19 Ghosts III
20 Ghosts III
24 Ghosts III
28 Ghosts IV
31 Ghosts IV
35 Ghosts IV
36 Ghosts IV
37 Ghosts


The Slip:
1,000,000
Letting You
Discipline
Echoplex
Lights In The Sky


Hesitation Marks:
Copy Of A
Find My Way
Satellite
Various Methods Of Escape
While I'm Still Here

[Emil Dorbell]

After realizing NTAE was probably such a good release because with that length there's no filler or any weak tracks, I started thinking about this exact topic in regards to the previous albums since The Fragile. Here's what I came up with:

With Teeth
You Know What You Are
Only
Getting Smaller
Sunspots
The Line Begins To Blur
Beside You In Time
Right Where It Belongs

Year Zero
HYPERPOWER!
The Beginning of the End
The Good Soldier
Me, I'm Not
My Violent Heart
Meet Your Master
The Great Destroyer
Zero Sum
In This Twilight

The Slip
999,999
1,000,000
Letting You
Head Down
Corona Radiata
Lights In The Sky

Hesitation Marks
The Eater Of Dreams
Copy of A
Find My Way
All Time Low
Various Methods Of Escape
I Would For You
In Two
While I'm Still Here
Black Noise

[OSLIN]

Hate Machine

Head Like A Hole
Terrible Lie
Sanctified
Sin
Twist

[Tommy_Macbeth]

The Slip:

1. 1,000,000
2. Discipline
3. Lights in the Sky
4. Head Down
5. The Four of Us Are Dying

On any given day I would replace Head Down with Echoplex depending on my mood.

[wizfan]

NIN-SUFFERABLE PAIN
You thought Merzbow's Music for Bondage Performance was arduous? From the man who brought you such agonizing classics such as "Fist Fuck" and "Screaming Slave" comes a brand spanking new (pun intended) release guaranteed to make your kinkiest fantasies more violent and sweaty than ever. NIN <3s BDSM.

01. Closer (Precursor)
02. Memorabilia
03. March of the Fuckheads
04. All the Pigs, All Lined Up
05. At the Heart of it All
06. Eraser (Reduction)
07. Reptilian
08. Self Destruction, Final

"You can dance to a lot of it. You can fuck to a lot of it. Or all of it, depending on what you're into." - Trent Reznor

[Tommy_Macbeth]

I decided to combine Year Zero & Not the Actual Events into one album:

1. The Beginning of the End
2. The Warning
3. Capital G
4. Dear World
5. Survivalism
6. The Good Soldier
7. She's Gone Away
8. Me, I'm Not
9. Branches/Bones (Second Act Begins)
10. The Great Destroyer
11. In This Twilight
12. The Idea of You
13. Zero Sum
14. Burning Bright (Field on Fire)

I tried to make it a coherent narrative with a break in between. It's two acts, with act two starting with 'Branches and Bones' ("

Feels like I've been here before")

Color-coded the words according to their part in the story so it would make more sense.

[Archive_Reports]

[wt]

The Line Begins to Blur
Sunspots
Non-Entity
Home
Love is Not Enough

tds

Burn
The Becoming
I Do Not Want This
Ruiner
Eraser

Y_Z

Meet Your Master
Vessel
The Greater Good
Zero Sum
The Great Destroyer

TF

Somewhat Damaged
The Perfect Drug
Where is Everybody (version)
Even Deeper
The Fragile
The Way Out is Through
We're in This Together
The Wretched
The Big Come Down
No, You Don't
Please
The Mark Has Been Made
The Frail

[elevenism]

This is Definitely About Drugs LP

1. Mr Self Destruct
2. The Perfect Drug
3. Me I'm Not
4. Please
5. Something i can Never Have
6. The Big Come Down
7. Love is Not Enough
8. Every Day is Exactly the Same
9. 1,000,000
10. Discipline
11. You Know What You Are
12. The Way Out is Through

[neorev]

Rulebreakers! All of you!

[wizfan]

Rulebreakers! All of you!

I didn't break any rules! Everything i used was from the TDS era!

[OSLIN]

I didn't break any rules! Everything i used was from the TDS era!

Brown-noser

[neorev]

I didn't break any rules! Everything i used was from the TDS era!

I think you're taking this too personally. There were two recent posts that broke the rules. It was not directed at you.

Someone made a Year Zero/Not An Actual Events album and another was a compilation of drug oriented tracks lol.

It was a joke, for one thing, since I was tsk tsk tsk'd for making a multi album compilation that didn't follow the rules.

You ok @wizfan ? That's 2 pissy posts right after each other with you quoting me. Did I somehow offend you?

[wizfan]

I think you're taking this too personally. There were two recent posts that broke the rules. It was not directed at you.

Someone made a Year Zero/Not An Actual Events album and another was a compilation of drug oriented tracks lol.

It was a joke, for one thing, since I was tsk tsk tsk'd for making a multi album compilation that didn't follow the rules.

You ok @wizfan ? That's 2 pissy posts right after each other with you quoting me. Did I somehow offend you?

No, you didn't. It's okay, man.

[Tommy_Macbeth]

My B, I just thought it would be cool to combine two albums into one.

[OSLIN]

My B, I just thought it would be cool to combine two albums into one.

Get your life together! Come on, this is serious business.

[Tommy_Macbeth]

The Fragile:

-Somewhat Damaged
-TDTWWA
-The Frail
-The Wretched
-Just Like You Imagined
-The Fragile
-La Mer
-The Way Out Is Through
-Into The Void
-Where Is Everybody?
-The Mark Has Been Made
-Starf#ckers
-The Big Come Down
-AATCHB
-We're In This Together

[jmtd]

999,999
Head Down
Lights In The Sky
Corona Radiata
Demon Seed

[Tiger_Stealth]

Hesitation Marks:

Copy Of A
Came Back Haunted
Various Methods Of Escape
I Would For You
In Two

[Zur En Arrh]

The fragile as one album.

Somewhat damaged.
Tdtwwa
The frail
The fragile
Please
The wretched
The mark has been made.
Even deeper
Ilftjyf
The big come down.
Underneath it all.
La mer
The great collapse.

[Failure]

Hesitation Marks:

Copy Of A
Came Back Haunted
Various Methods Of Escape
I Would For You
In Two

This! Various Methods is the single most underrated NIN tune. Well, since Sunspots has now become overrated.

[leftshoe18]

I made my own version of Bleedthrough a while ago.

1. All The Love In The World (extended intro w/ Twilight Zone sample)
2. Message To No One (AI speech over the instrumental of The Tradition by Halsey with some elements of EDIETS)
3. The Collector (alternate bridge/outro with demo lyrics and guitar solo taken from rehearsal audio)
4. You Know What You Are (combination of the WT version and the Doom OST version with a sample of HLAH (Opal) outro)
5. Non-Entity
6. Every Day Is Exactly The Same
7. Only (with alternate outro with demo vocals)
8. The Life You Didn't Lead (a slight remix of The Lovers with some elements of The Hand That Feeds)
9. Love Is Not Enough (with live version drum loop and alternate outro)
10. With Teeth
11. Home
12. I Think We're Past That Now (slightly remixed with some elements of EDIETS)
13. The Idea Of You
14. The Line Begins To Blur (with alternate second chorus and guitar solo using bits from BYIT version)
15. Beside You In Time
16. Right Where It Belongs (album version instrumental with V2 vocals)