Which NIN songs did you see the live debut of?

[Ryan]

Offhand and standing on the train I remember seeing the first time The Good Soldier and Me, I'm Not were played back in 2007.

What are yours?

[clodhopper]

In This Twilight - Seattle 2008.

[sheepdean]

Survivalism I believe. And if you count it, Cars.

[halo33]

The Perfect Drug - Red Rocks July 21st, 2014.


But seriously, not counting covers.

In Two - Mohegan Sun October 12th 2013
A Warm Place - Webster Hall August 23rd 2009
The Beginning of the End - Carling Academy March 8th 2007

(great thread idea btw)

[pwing47]

The Perfect Drug - Red Rocks July 21st, 2014.

We can dream. I'll be there with you when it happens :)

Lots of stuff from HM at Xcel Energy Center Sep 28, 2013:
All Time Low
Satellite
I Would For You
Running
While I'm Still Here / Black Noise

[Ryan]

(great thread idea btw)

I know, I'm awesome. :)

[Dinki Di]

All The Love In The World - San Antonio, 11/05/13.

[Lerxto]

Disappointed and What If We Could? - 07/28/13 South Korea.

[jessamineny]

8 Ghosts I
Gone, Still
Right Where It Belongs V2
Lights in the Sky
A Warm Place
In Two

If you include covers...
Metal
I'm Afraid of Americans
Kick in the Eye
I Die: You Die
Down in the Park
Love Like Anthrax

[skullboy0]

We can dream. I'll be there with you when it happens :)

Lots of stuff from HM at Xcel Energy Center Sep 28, 2013:
All Time Low
Satellite
I Would For You
Running
While I'm Still Here / Black Noise

Mine were already posted. Although if the "original" setlist from Lollapalooza 2013 would've been played I would've seen "Everything".;)

[MrSlfDstruct]

Just Lights In The Sky for me. Although I did see the return of Now I'm Nothing after quite a long hiatus.

[FULLMETAL]

Oh man, off the top of my head: Last/WITT @ Lisbon, Copy of A/Came Back Haunted/Find My Way/Sanctified (new arrangement) @ Fuji Rock, Hand Covers Bruise @ Tokyo.

Looking back through Tension: ATL/Satellite/IWFY/Running/WISH @ St.Paul & VMOE @ Kansas City.

According to NINTOURHISTORY.com: Just Like You Imagined @ Cleveland, Survivalism @ Barcelona, 10 Ghosts II @ Greensboro, 28 Ghosts IV @ Gwinnett, 32 Ghosts IV @ Knoxville, Heresy @ Lisbon (unless you count a warm-up show in 1994?) & AWP @ Webster Hall.

If we're counting covers: We Take Mystery (To Bed) @ Sunrise, Ice Age/BBB @ Tokyo, Banged & Blown Through @ Atlanta, Metal/I'm Afraid of Americans @ WPB, Kick In The Eye @ NYC & I Die:YouDie @ LA.

[Ryan]

Oh man, off the top of my head: Last/WITT @ Lisbon, Copy of A/Came Back Haunted/Find My Way/Sanctified (new arrangement) @ Fuji Rock, Hand Covers Bruise @ Tokyo.

Looking back through Tension: ATL/Satellite/IWFY/Running/WISH @ St.Paul & VMOE @ Kansas City.

According to NINTOURHISTORY.com: Just Like You Imagined @ Cleveland, Survivalism @ Barcelona, 10 Ghosts II @ Greensboro, 28 Ghosts IV @ Gwinnett, 32 Ghosts IV @ Knoxville, Heresy @ Lisbon (unless you count a warm-up show in 1994?).

If we're counting covers: We Take Mystery (To Bed) @ Orlando, Ice Age/BBB @ Tokyo, Banged & Blown Through @ Atlanta, Metal/I'm Afraid of Americans @ WPB, Kick In The Eye @ NYC & I Die:YouDie @ LA.

That's impressive!

[slave2thewage]

I think just TBOTE, but we heard them rehearsing The Warning at Wolverhampton in 07 and it wasn't played until the LITS tour.

[TheBang]

None, except Red Scabs and Beat My Guest with guest artists. :(

[BenAkenobi]

The great destroyer

[martin_b]

"Echoplex (Remix)" in Poznan, 2009-06-23. ;-)

[katara]

It was just The Beginning Of The End. Edit: Does Cars w/Gary Numan count?

But I also saw the last performances of both Deep and Now I'm Nothing. They will probably be played again, but for songs that are rarely played anyway, for me this feels like an achievement.

[SM Rollinger]

All Time Low
Satellite
I Would For You
Running
While I'm Still Here / Black Noise
Ditto, I was at the 9.28 Xcel Energy Center show too. Good stuff :)

[theimage13]

None.

Now you've made me sad. I hope you're happy.

*cough*

[frankie teardrop]

a warm place (webster hall)

i thought i saw 8 ghosts I debut, but i guess it was played one other time in ohio, a few days before philly...

[dvdglss]

We Take Mystery (To Bed) @ Orlando

Sunrise was the day before. We got that first ;) and I was there!

[FULLMETAL]

Sunrise was the day before. We got that first ;) and I was there! Me too! Thanks for the update.

[spiralhate]

We're In This Together - Lisbon 11th February 2007

[laci]

No first debut, but I was there when The Collector returned in 2009. It was in Romania.

[Winter Is Coming]

Meet Your Master
17 Ghosts
21 Ghosts

All three in Calgary in 2008

5 Ghosts Edmonton, also 2008


The Ghosts stuff, I think is more coincidence than anything because it was at the beginning of the tour but Meet Your Master was cool because it has not been played a lot since.

[ekrekel]

All The Love In The World - San Antonio, 11/05/13.
First Live Performance:
ATLITW - San Antonio 2014
I Die You Die - LA Echoplex

Looking through my show history, I cannot belive how awesome the setlist for the Austin 2009 show was: http://www.nintourhistory.com/concert.php?concertid=777. Having not seen any Fragile or TDS era shows getting hit with Heresy, The Becoming, Piggy(NCSMN), Not So Pretty Now, Fragile, Gone/Still, I Do Not Want This, Lights In The Sky, Dead Souls (all firsts for me after 10 shows) was epic.

[icecream]

None, but the Victoria show I was at was filmed so that's pretty cool.

[demo]

Just Lights In The Sky for me. Although I did see the return of Now I'm Nothing after quite a long hiatus.
Tampa '09? :D

[K-Rice]

I saw Survivalism with Saul Williams and Banged and Blown Through during NINJA. Also, it was my 19th birthday!

[thevoid99]

I saw Survivalism with Saul Williams and Banged and Blown Through during NINJA. Also, it was my 19th birthday!

Awesome! I was at that show.

[SIR.LONDONCLEANLILY]

The Big Comedown @ the Dallas Fragility Tour with A Perfect Circle!

[Callahan]

Meet Your Master
17 Ghosts
21 Ghosts

All three in Calgary in 2008

5 Ghosts Edmonton, also 2008


The Ghosts stuff, I think is more coincidence than anything because it was at the beginning of the tour but Meet Your Master was cool because it has not been played a lot since.

Exact same for me, I made it to both of those shows as well. Don't think I've had the privilege of catching any other live debuts.

hopefully that will change though, come July when I catch them on the first show of the NA Tour in Vegas.

[KStawski]

I was lucky enough to see them open with Pilgrimage into Mr. Self Destruct during the winter leg of the With Teeth tour in Champaign, IL.

[SIR.LONDONCLEANLILY]

I don't want to piss on your parade but playing the album version of a track over the PA doesn't exactly count in my opinion.

[jmtd]

No firsts afaik, but I saw the last performance of With Teeth (http://www.ninwiki.com/2007/02/26_Manchester,_UK).

Edit: Ps sheepdean I dunno why you (and others) waste your time with edits like these (http://www.ninwiki.com/index.php?title=2007/02/26_Manchester,_UK&diff=29886&oldid=29884) (removing all but the first occurrence of a wiki link). I still think it makes the wiki harder to read. It's just blindly following a flawed policy from WP, imho.

[slopesandsam]

Capital G in Melbourne in 2007.

I can't remember if it was at the show where Trent cracked the shits during Hurt and cut the concert short, or the blisteringly awesome show the next night where the band came out blasting.