Custom Setlists

[Ripe(withdecay)]

With Nine Inch Nails touring this year and next year, let's see what everyone wants them to play with custom setlists.

[ManBurning]

Fragile from beginning to end and i'm happy.

I honestly was 100% sure it was going to be fragility 3.0, especially with how secretive he was with the "where is the Fragile deluxe edition?"
However, what he said recently to NME throws that speculation all out the window...

I'm gonna paraphrase it here because I don't remember the exact quote and i'm too lazy to go find it for the purpose of writing this, but it was something like...

"The new tour isn't going to be songs that most people want, we've done the whole rock 'n roll thing to death, this is NIN in a new light, reconstructed songs"

Sooooo, by that comment, I think Fragility 3.0 is officially thrown out the window. I think he's going with a STILL approach for this album. Songs that are reworked like how the STILL ones were (The Becoming, The Fragile, TDTWWA, SICNH) However.... that makes me wonder why they need 6 people on stage for that, those songs are VERY stripped down where like 2-3 people could get away with playing them.

So, the only other thing I can think he is doing this tour is remixed songs live.

[sheepdean]

PHM from beginning to end, with Ghosts either side to make it a full set.


I CAN FUCKING DREAM MAN

[SM Rollinger]

Mr Self Destruct
Piggy
Heresy
MotP
Closer
Ruiner
Becoming
IDNWT
Big man w/ a gun
warm Place
Eraser
Reptile
Downward Spiral
Hurt

But with the original arrangement of closer this time! and maybe the 1994 version of Big Man too, with the extended intro and the samples and shit. Trent can even kick it old school and tell the crowd before they play it "if anybody wants to hurt themselfs, do it, (deep breath) NOOOOOWWWWWW!!!!!"

[gladcarrot]

A Violet Fluid
All The Love In The World
Where Is Everybody?
My Violent Heart
Kinda I Want To
Maybe Just Once
Purest Feeling
Driver Down
Memorabilia
10 Miles High
I'm Looking Forward To Joining You, Finally
The Persistence Of Loss
And All That Could Have Been
Leaving Hope
Sunspots
Demon Seed
The Four Of Us Are Dying
Zero-Sum
Underneath It All
The Perfect Drug
Ripe (With Decay)

[Halo Infinity]

PHM from beginning to end, with Ghosts either side to make it a full set.


I CAN FUCKING DREAM MAN
Now that you mention it, oh hell yes. I'd love to be able to see That's What I Get live. (Aside from also being one of those fans that'll be able to say that they've been to a full NIN album show and actually mean it.) :D

Oo-whoa-a-oh!!!


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LYjKlhy0GKc

And it would be oh so heavenly to see Ringfinger live.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oXJOtp2fmro

Oh yes, you can certainly count me in on that dream all right! :D

[NotoriousTIMP]

If I was a betting man (ie. Jinsai) I would say Trent, Adrian, Illan, and Eric will stand off stage each manning a spot light with a different color. They will then start to slowly fade each color in and out on Alessandro while he plays a set that consists of a 2 hour rendition of "Erased, Over, Out" (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UpCQZSsdxpY).

[slave2thewage]

Trent's going to prove that he's still relevant by playing all the songs the kids are into like I Got You Babe and Danny Boy.

[Frozen Beach]

I want to hear a modern day take of the Purest Feeling version of Sanctified. Yes, wrap your head around that.

[AgentofChaos]

1. Tetsuo: The Bullet Man
2. Mr. Self Destruct
3. Ruiner
4. The Frail
5. The Wretched
6. Eraser
7. Ghosts I
8. Beside You in Time
9. Another Version of the Truth
10. The Day The World Went Away
11. Were in this Together
12. The Mark Has Been Made
13. The Great Below
14. Ghosts 27
15. Ghosts 28
16. Non Entity
17. Leaving Hope
18. Ripe (With Decay)
-----------------------
19. A Warm Place
20. And All That Could Have Been
21. Ghosts 34
22. Terrible Lie

[jaypayton]

im sure Trent will read these setlists suggestions...totally...

[MrSlfDstruct]

im sure Trent will read these setlists suggestions...totally...

I don't think anyone is under the impression that he will, or that that has any bearing on people contributing to the thread . . .

[BenAkenobi]

Somewhat damaged
Sunspots
Sin
Slipping away
Sunday bloody sunday
Self destruction, final
Screaming slave
Something i can never have
Survivalism
Sanctified
Star----ers, inc
Suck

[wizfan]

Covers of Thomas Dolby and Pere Ubu all night.

[seasonsinthesky]

if there's no "10 Miles High" and "The Perfect Drug," i guess i'll continue wondering how they'd pull them off live.

[Collin]

made a dream setlist and incorporated some currently unplayed tracks. Some of these choices don't seem that unlikely given the kind of setlists we were given during the Wave Goodbye tour:

1. The Way Out Is Through
2. Ruiner
3. We're In This Together
4. Last
5. Terrible Lie
6. Head Down
7. The Bullet Man
8. The Line Begins to Blur
9. My Violent Heart
10. 13 Ghosts II
11. The Day The World Went Away
12. The Fragile
13. Beside You In Time
14. The Downward Spiral
15. 1,000,000
16. Mr. Self Destruct
17. Just Like You Imagined
18. Into The Void
19. Somewhat Damaged
20. Reptile
21. Demon Seed
22. The Great Destroyer
23. The Perfect Drug
24. Right Where It Belongs

Encore-

25. 10 Miles High
26. The Becoming
27. The Big Come Down
28. Head Like A Hole
29. All The Love In The World

[fillow]

I just wish they'd open with Ghosts 27. Especially since it's Belew's song. That guitar is just sick.

[Halo Infinity]

This is just another dream set-list of mine.

1. Pinion
2. Pilgrimage
3. Mr Self Destruct
4. Piggy
5. Help Me I Am In Hell
6. Happiness In Slavery
7. Burn
8. Adrift And At Peace
9. The Fragile
10. Just Like You Imagined
11. The Great Destroyer
12. The Line Begins To Blur
13. The Day The World Went Away
14. A Warm Place
15. Into The Void
16. Starfuckers, Inc.
17. La Mer
18. The Great Below
19. Suck
20. Only

-Encore-

21. Echoplex
22. Head Like A Hole
23. Closer
24. The Only Time
25. Home
26. Down In It

[slave2thewage]

Angel With the Scabbed Wings
Get Your Gunn
Cake and Sodomy
Dried Up, Tied and Dead to the World
Tourniquet
(The Tourniquet Prosthetic Dance Mix outro)
Lunchbox
Sweet Dreams (Are Made of This)
(Eurythmics cover)
Minute of Decay
Little Horn
(With "1999" spoken word intro)
Apple of Sodom
Antichrist Superstar
The Beautiful People
The Reflecting God
Irresponsible Hate Anthem
Man That You Fear

Oh, wait...

[reseen_lamenti]

^ But really though, I'd pay good money to see NIN interpretations of these.
(doesn't TR have writing credits for like 20% of ACSS?)

[Reznor2112]

Hand Covers Bruise
Zoo Station
Discipline
Head Down
Into the void
Slipping Away
Sunspots
We're In this Together
(new song 1)
la mer
The Great Below

Ghost 35
Kinda I want to
Sin
My Violent Heart
The Great collapse
The Wretched
March of the Pigs
Terrible Lie
The Hand that feeds
Head like a Hole
Big Man with a Gun

A Warm Place
Something I can Never Have
Heresy
Dead Souls
(New Song 2)
Reptile
The Four of Us are Dying (fading into...)
Appendage
Everyday is Exactly the Same
The Fragile

[BRoswell]

The Frail (seguing into a mashup of intro tracks: The New Flesh/Pinion/Hyperpower!/999,999)
Mr. Self Destruct
Sin
March Of The Pigs
You Know What You Are?
Gave Up
Help Me I Am In Hell
La Mer
13 Ghosts II
31 Ghosts IV
Just Like You Imagined
Eraser
Burn
Wish
The Hand That Feeds
Head Like A Hole

Encore:
Just Like You Imagined
Reptile
Happiness In Slavery
Into The Void (with Slipping Away outro)

[[Shep]]

Tetsuo live would be so intense!

[BenAkenobi]

won't happen. betting 10 bucks. who plays with me?

[[Shep]]

won't happen. betting 10 bucks. who plays with me?
I don't think it will, I just think it would be amazing.

[hologram parade]

Main Show:

Ripe (With Decay) Intro (pre show)
--
10 Miles High
Somewhat Damaged
Last
Ruiner
Piggy
Metal
4 Ghosts I
The Becoming
--
1 Ghost I/1 Ghost II
Gone, Still
La Mer
The Great Below
The Mark Has Been Made
The Fragile
Non Entity
Even Deeper (Telefon Tel Aviv Remix)
The Way Out Is Through
--
Were In This Together
The Great Collapse
Sunspots
37 Ghost
Reptile (Stripped Down/2006 Radio version)
10 Ghosts II
Into the Void

Encore:

Just like You Imagined
Dead Souls
The Good Soldier
Echoplex
12 Ghost II
Tetsou Theme!

[theSplinter04]

999,999 intro
KICK OUT THE JAMS MOTHERFUCKER
Getting Smaller (Flip Flop Flip Flop)
Kinda I Want To
Starfuckers, Inc. (Version)
The Hand That Feeds DFA Mix
Starfuckers, Inc. (Version)
- Pilgrimage interlude
The Collector
Capital G Remix (Clean)
Starfuckers, Inc. (Version)
Not So Pretty Now
Hurt
Hurt
Me I'm Not Olof Dreijer 30 Min. Outro

[stefler]

I totally love the set NIN played on 6th Nov 2008 in Atlatic City.

That would be my custom set from that gig + 3 extra songs:

Pinion
Love is Not Enough
Terrible Lie
1,000,000
Letting You
March of the Pigs
Piggy (Album version)
The Frail
The Wretched
The Collector
Survivalism
Reptile
Closer
Discipline
The Beginning of the End
Ghosts 31
Wish
Head Down
Gave Up
The Line Begins To Blur
Only
God Given
Down in It
Hurt
Starfuckers Inc.
The Hand That Feeds
Head Like a Hole
-----
Suck
We're In This Together
Starf**ers Inc.

[pukkelpop]

A Violet Fluid
All The Love In The World
Where Is Everybody?
My Violent Heart
Kinda I Want To
Maybe Just Once
Purest Feeling
Driver Down
Memorabilia
10 Miles High
I'm Looking Forward To Joining You, Finally
The Persistence Of Loss
And All That Could Have Been
Leaving Hope
Sunspots
Demon Seed
The Four Of Us Are Dying
Zero-Sum
Underneath It All
The Perfect Drug
Ripe (With Decay)
these unplayed songs, and 2 classic party songs like SIN live (Trent, don't skip this one..):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TaRz1yE_n5c

[somewhat_]

HyperPower!
The Great Destroyer
Hapiness in Slavery
Deep
And All That Could Have Been
Leaving Hope
The Four of Us are Dying
Demon Seed
We're In this Together
My Violent Heart
Slipping Away
The Perfect Drug
Sunspots
Where is Everybody?
Ruiner
The Becoming
A Warm Place
The Only Time
Zero Sum

Not in any particular order because it's so much awesomeness that I can't even fathom putting it in order

[gorny540]

That's What I Get needs to return in the worst way...

[kercyx]

these unplayed songs, and 2 classic party songs like SIN live (Trent, don't skip this one..):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TaRz1yE_n5c

This is by far my favorite live version of Sin, so much energy, Trent doing the synth solo, if only Rob shared the video he took from this night...

[pukkelpop]

^^i asked Rob multiple times. maybe something went wrong with the filming; cause this gig and this song were perfect...

[kercyx]

^^i asked Rob multiple times. maybe something went wrong with the filming; cause this gig and this song were perfect... Just the audio file of this song would make me happy ! ( and if I keep dreaming, a soundboard audio for Ruiner would make me go completely nuts !) Please Trent, don't skip Ruiner for this tour, pleeeeease !!

[Amari2677]

I'd kill to have this setlist…

Now I’m Nothing
Terrible Lie
Sin
The Line Begins to Blur
(New Song 1)
Piggy
Reptile
We’re in this Together
Even Deeper
(New Song 2)
4 Ghosts I (slow transition into…)
La Mer
The Great Below
The Way Out is Through
Last
Sunspots
(New Song 3)
The Good Soldier
The Great Destroyer
Down In It
12 Ghost II
Hurt

---encore---
The Day the World Went Away
Discipline
Head Like a Hole
A Warm Place
Something I Can Never Have (still)

[fillow]

If they plan to play Closer again... for the love of God please add back the full long ending (as it was played in Self Destruct and Fragility eras). I don't even care about original or The Only Time breakdown. That old ending was SICK (http://tinyurl.com/mq43v9y)

[AbjectMark]

I don't mind as long as "and all that could have been" is in it somewhere

[ryanmcfly]

I would like to see in no particular order:

The Day the World Went Away
Ruiner
Mr. Self Destruct
Eraser
We're In This Together
The Big Come Down
Head Like a Hole
Terrible Lie
Sin
Something I Can Never Have
Demon Seed
Wish
Gave Up
Sunspots
Love is Not Enough
Me, I'm Not
God Given
Meet Your Master
the Great Destroyer
In This Twilight
Hurt

And sprinkle four or five new songs in there as well.

[laz001]

Why is no one mentioning happiness in slavery? Its rarely played and must be killer live...and surely putting in a request for perfect drug wouldn't hurt lo,! ��

[billpulsipher]

I don't think Trent can pull off Happiness anymore vocally

[Jim]

Now that you mention it, oh hell yes. I'd love to be able to see That's What I Get live. (Aside from also being one of those fans that'll be able to say that they've been to a full NIN album show and actually mean it.) :D

Oo-whoa-a-oh!!!


And it would be oh so heavenly to see Ringfinger live.


Oh yes, you can certainly count me in on that dream all right! :D

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Nine-Inch-Nails-set-list-Newcastle-Riverside-7th-September-1991-/190856328998?pt=UK_Magazines&hash=item2c6fec7726

[hobochic]

I don't think Trent can pull off Happiness anymore vocally

What's with all these urban myths of impossible nin live songs? Adjust them, perform them. Enough with safe territory terrible songs that were never good - SICNH, im looking at you - Bring out the hard ones.

[thefragile_jake]

Deep sounds amazing live....I'd love to see that and Metal make a return to the setlist this year.

[jmtd]

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Nine-Inch-Nails-set-list-Newcastle-Riverside-7th-September-1991-/190856328998?pt=UK_Magazines&hash=item2c6fec7726

Holy shit. First uk gig was Newcastle riverside? Most legendary ex club in ncl. Rumour has it the sound system was taken straight from the hacienda. They ran the stonelove night there (Madchester) for ages before it became a national thing. God I miss that place.

[jmtd]

I want to see WITT again, and MYM and ITT for the first time. Edit : and demon seed.

[frankie teardrop]

Deep sounds amazing live....I'd love to see that and Metal make a return to the setlist this year.

i never loved deep, but would welcome it as a change of pace... but metal, while excellent, overstayed its welcome on the ninja/wave goodbye shows. i saw six of those and it was played every single time. if it weren't so long and meandering, it would be less of an issue. the repetition and drone was enjoyable on record and at the first few shows, but it got a bit monotonous over repeated setlist appearances. the cover aspect isn't doing it any favors either.

i'm not one to speculate all that much, but would obviously love to see we're in this together, as far as songs that have rarely been played go.

[andre78]

Insert a few new songs here and there, and voila: my dream setlist.

Mr. Self Destruct
Terrible Lie
Letting You
Sin
March Of The Pigs
The Frail
The Wretched
Closer
Gave Up
Reptile
Wish
Last
Suck
Eraser
La Mer
Into The Void
Discipline
That's What I Get
The Great Destroyer
Survivalism
The Hand That Feeds
-encore-
The Fragile
Down In It
Head Like A Hole
In This Twilight

[snaapz]

The Day The World Went Away
New Song from Halo 28
The Collector
New Song from Halo 28
Help Me I Am In Hell
The Line Begins to Blur
8 Ghosts I
Came Back Haunted
New song from Halo 28
God Given
31 Ghosts IV
Beside You In Time
Dead Souls
New Song from Halo 28
The Big Come Down
Please
Where is Everybody
Ruiner
Heresy/The Great Destroyer mix
March of the Pigs
New Song from Halo 28
The Fragile (With organ outro)
Piggy
New Song from Halo 28
Demon Seed
Lights in the Sky
Ripe (with decay)

[jmtd]

The line begins to blur was awesome live. It would be nice to see that again.

[Ryan]

The line begins to blur was awesome live. It would be nice to see that again.

May I pls bless you with my recording?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C0B6kncKKeY&fmt=22

[jmtd]

Nice, thanks. The show they played it at I watched was http://www.ninwiki.com/2005/07/10_Manchester,_UK with no known recordings unfortunately. There is one from a London show a few days later: http://www.reflectinginthechrome.com/shows/2005/20050714.html

[thefragile_jake]

Time to make a fun Tension 2013 setlist....this is going off only hearing Came Back Haunted off of Hesitation Marks so it'd be interesting to see after the record comes out if these random songs I pick would be in good placement.

The Eater of Dreams
Find My Way
Terrible Lie
Even Deeper
The Collector
Running
All Time Low
March of the Pigs
La Mer / Into the Void
Happiness in Slavery
14 Ghosts II
The Fragile
Everything
Came Back Haunted
A Warm Place / Eraser
Only
Deep
Head Like a Hole

Encore:
The Day The World Went Away
Various Methods of Escape
The Hand That Feeds
And All That Could Have Been

[hani]

pilgrimage
---
copy of a
1,000,000
terrible lie
the collector
came back haunted
discipline
the frail/the wretched
closer
survivalism
TBCD
piggy
god given
head down
the warning
LITS
the fragile
the great below
BYIT
vessel
HLAH
---
somewhat damaged
the line begins to blur
suck
TDTWWA
happiness in slavery
echoplex
hurt

[billpulsipher]

compare these setlists to what they are actually playing....lol obv T Rez feels just a wee bit different

[BRoswell]

compare these setlists to what they are actually playing....lol obv T Rez feels just a wee bit different


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qS7nqwGt4-I

[hellospaceboy]

Heresy (TDS version)
Where is everybody
Sin
Burn
Eraser
The Fragile
Last
Echoplex
We're In This Together
Copy of A
Get Down Make Love
Twist
Zero Sum
A Warm Place

Encore:
Hello Spaceboy
the Perfect Drug

[Javra]

This is just way too hard.

1 : HYPERPOWER
2 : Mr. Self Destruct
3 : The Beggining Of The End
4 : Heresy
5 : Gave Up
6 : March Of The Pigs
7 : The Line Begins To Blur
8 : Into The Void
9 : The Great Below
10 : Beside You In Time
11 : Ruiner
12 : Wish
13 : The Great Destroyer
14 : The Big Come Down
15 : My Violent Heart
16 : The Fragile
17 : A Warm Place
18 : Hurt

19 : Now I'm Nothing (Crawling on the ground style)
20 : Terrible Lie
21 : Dead Souls
22 : Down In It
23 : Head Like A Hole
24 : We're In This Together

[draven]

this is probably just one of the hundreds of setlist ideas that float around inside my head.

pinion
the beginning of the end
march of the pigs
head down
sin
into the void
down in it
piggy
the way out is through
suck
the only time
no, you don't
closer
ruiner
now i'm nothing
terrible lie
1,000,000
the becoming
the frail
the wretched

encore:
just like you imagined
eraser
reptile
head like a hole
something i can never have

[Emil Dorbell]

I made this list looking at the different tracklists, starting chronologically. This made me painfully aware of how little I appreciate the "new" stuff (post-Fragile). Guess I'm that guy!

Somewhat Damaged
Terrible Lie
Last
Piggy
Help Me I Am In Hell
Happiness in Slavery
Suck
No You Don't
The Mark Has Been Made
Even Deeper
And All That Could Have Been
Ruiner
The Becoming
I Do Not Want This
A Warm Place
Eraser
Reptile
The Downward Spiral
Hurt
--
Encore:
I'm Looking Forward To Joining You, Finally
The Big Come Down
Underneath It All
--
Encore 2:
Head Like A Hole

[pigpen]

Lights in the Sky
The Frail
The Wretched
Find My Way
The Persistence of Loss
The Fragile
The Great Below
The Mark Has Been Made
The Day the World Went Away
La Mer
Into The Void
Just Like You Imagined
Corona Radiata
Leaving Hope
Eraser
Right Where it Belongs v.2
A Warm Place
Hurt.

It'd be a cool set if he went on tour in a Still/Unplugged type of way..
Acoustic guitars, piano, cellos, upright bass, etc. He should do that when
he get's too old to be "ROCK SHOW" TR.

[telee.kom]

Now I'm Nothing
Terrible Lie
Sanctified (New)
Home
Mr. Self Destruct
Burn
Help Me I'm In Hell
Last
The Way Out Is Through (New)
Somewhat Damaged
Heresy
We're In This Together
Sin
Ruiner
The Warning
Physical

I made a YT playlist (https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL5_Mtm6vGv-OcSYPp2FQhqQxeRUABiOY6&feature=mh_lolz) and it sounds rad!

[OSLIN]

setlist
hurt (crc version)
the new flesh/pinion (intro)
terrible lie
last
please
vessel
running
an itch
the becoming (still)
eraser
reptile
the great below
28 ghosts iv
copy of a
mr self destruct
head like a hole
march of the pigs
suck
heresy
head down
it catches up with you
while i'm still here
black noise

encore
the way out is through
the line begins to blur
the perfect drug
we're in this together now
right where it belongs (v2)
and all that could have been/leaving hope (outro)

[EndlessLoveless]

In this order...excluding HM songs i havent heard (all but CBH)

the way out is through
mr self destruct
were in this together
terrible lie
heresy
march of the pigs
where is everybody?
the line begins to blur
survivalism
the good soldier
and all that could have been
ruiner
the great destroyer
1,000,000
happiness in slavery
into the void
home
the day the world went away
came back haunted
head down
beside you in time
somewhat damaged
wish

[EndlessLoveless]

fuck i forgot the becoming and the perfect drug...

[bobbie solo]

fuck i forgot the becoming and the perfect drug...

i dont think i want to hear how Trent would interpret The Becoming with this lineup. I think the version they did back in '09 was terrible. Robin's guitar sounded so goofy.

[EndlessLoveless]

^^Really? It def sounds different but i think they nailed it. As far as the studio version goes, the break in the middle might be my favorite part of the entire album TDS. Its just perfect, the acoustics, backround machinery noises and the annie line...and then it just blows up.

[bobbie solo]

yeah i wanted it to have more power behind the guitars. it just sounded flimsy to me overall.

[nobies]

The Frail (Version)
Where Is Everybody? (Version)
In Motion
Discipline
Sunspots
The Day The Whole World Went Away
Home
Piggy (Nothing Can Stop Me Now)
The Perfect Drug
La Mer
Adrift and at Peace
Burn
I'm Afraid of Americans
In The Hall Of The Mountain King
Closer
Happiness In Slavery
Reptile
Ringfinger
Wish
And All That Could've Been
Leaving Hope

encore

The Beginning of the End
The Collector
Eraser
Heresy
Starfuckers Inc.
All The Love In The World

[Inkë]

01- copy of a
02- head like a hole
03- terrible lie
04- march of the pigs
05- head down
06- I'm afraid of americans
07- burn
08- the frail
09- the wretched
10- sunspots
11- sanctified
12- piggy
13- the four of us are dying
14- the mark has been made
15- wish
16- ruiner
17- reptile
18- gave up
19- me, i'm not
20- down in it
21- the hand that feeds
22- complication
encore
23- ringfinger
24- the day the world went away

(bonus : a song from HTDA featuring Mariqueen but with NIN band. Or Quake Theme.)

[Shadaloo]

Last (Butch Vig Remix)
Please
We're In This Together
Love Is Not Enough
Into The Void
Head Down
Ruiner
Just Like You Imagined
Even Deeper
Piggy
Meet Your Master
The Line Begins To Blur
StarFuckers, Inc.
The Day The World Went Away
And All That Could Have Been

Encore:
Every Day Is Exactly The Same
The Beginning Of The End
Sin
You Know WHat You Are?
Memorabilia
the Four Of Us Are Dying
The Big Come Down
The Downward Spiral
Head Like A Hole
Encore 2:
The Perfect Drug

I'm on crack, I know.

[SarahConnor]

The tour will likely differ from festival setlists that seem to be a pretty solid 'Greatest Hits' representation of the catalog. These tickets I have better be for 'March of the Pigs,' 'Wish,' 'Discipline' and 'Head Like A Hole.' Ain't gonna lie. 'Ripe,' 'Only-' those songs can remain on the CDs, thank you!

[dlb]

Right now, that's what my ultimate extended dream setlist for tension would look like from what we've heard already and what I personally think could work:

01. copy of a
02. dissapointed
03. came back haunted
04. march of the pigs
05. piggy
06. the frail
07. the wretched
08. la mer
09. into the void
10. terrible lie
11. sin
12. heresy
13. metal
14. I'm afraid od Americans
15. the becoming
16. burn
17. closer
18. gave up
(curtain down)
19. the downward spiral
20. eraser
21. me, I'm not
22. find my way
23. even deeper
24. the way out is through
(curtain up)
25. corona radiata/pinion
26. wish
27. help me I am in hell
28. happiness in slavery

(encore)
29. the day the world went away
30. hurt

(encore #2)
31. the hand that feeds
32. head like a hole

[intothevoid2007]

I see "SunSpots" on a lot of peoples' lists. I am very curious why this has never been played along with one of my other favorites "Where Is Everybody?" I heard a few people here at one of the concerts here a few years back (Vancouver maybe?) saying they heard them during warm-ups play "Sunspots" but it must have not sounded right to Trent....Don't understand the hatred either from him for "Where Is Everybody?"

[jmtd]

People's dream lists contain songs precisely because they haven't been played, or are rarely played. Just because they aren't played or played often doesn't mean Trent hates them. In the case of TPD band members have said a few times that it just didn't sound good live, they couldn't get it to gel into a setlist, etc.

[Dimitri.]

Part I :
The Way Out Is Through
Mr Self-Destruct
The Wretched
Vessel
Please
Appendage
March of the Pigs
Head Down
Piggy
The Becoming
I Do Not Want This
The Downward Spiral
Suck
Pilgrimage
Even Deeper
And All That Could Have Been

Part II :
Now I'm Nothing
Terrible Lie
Sin
Pinion
Happiness in Slavery
Something I Can Never Have
Beside You In Time
10 Miles High
My Violent Heart
The Great Destroyer
The Great Below
Underneath It All
Leaving Hope

Encore :
Somewhat Damaged
A Violet Fluid (intro) + Tetsuo
The Day The World Went Away
Zero-Sum

Almost 3 hours, but so perfect.

[Fist Fuck]

1. The Fragile (Album; Vinyl Version)
---
26. And All That Could Have Been


Edit: My 69th post, but this show would top the best 69.

[fillow]

my placeholder setlist for a nin+qotsa show

nin = songs that work without bass guitar.
qotsa = just a dream setlist

copy of a
wish
last
disappointed // heresy
terrible lie
march of the pigs
something i can never have // find my way
reptile
gave up
the warning // me, i'm not
the great destroyer // vessel
and all that could have been // beside you in time
lights in the sky
a warm place
somewhat damaged
no, you don't
mantra (feat. j-ho and mikey shoes)
happiness in slavery remixed
theme for tetsuo the bullet man
into the void
down in it
head like a hole
hurt

keep you eyes peeled
everybody knows that you are insane
in my head
my god is the sun
turnin' on the screw
sick sick sick
into the hollow
do it again
mexicola
born to hula
era vulgaris (feat t-rez)
kalopsia (feat t-rez)
someone's in the wolf
better living trough chemistry
you're so vague
a song for the deaf
you can't quit me baby
go with the flow
the fun machine took a shit! and died
misfit love
i appear missing
a song for the dead

[Halo Infinity]

1. All The Love In The World
2. Copy Of A
3. Down In It
4. Piggy
5. Home
6. Every Day Is Exactly The Same
7. Closer
8. The Only Time
9. Kinda I Want To
10. The Becoming
11. Satellite
12. Gave Up
13. The Big Come Down
14. Running
16. I'm Looking Forward To Joining You, Finally
17. Help Me I Am In Hell
18. Reptile
19. Black Noise
20. Happiness In Slavery
21. Head Like A Hole
22. Sunspots
23. Ringfinger

[Volband]

1. Pinion into Happiness In Slavery/ Pilgrimage into The Beginning Of The End / The New Flesh into Starfuckers Inc.
2. The Collector / Getting Smaller / That’s What I Get
3. Sin
4. And All That Could Have Been / Every Day Is Exactly The Same
5. # Rant 1 about Grammys, Labels, Spotify, etc.
6. Me I’m Not / Running / The Big Come Down
7. Meet You Master / No, You Don’t
8. The Great Destroyer
9. Ruiner / Last / March Of The Pigs
10. Wish / Gave Up / You Know What You Are
11. # Rant about you being the best fucking crowd, and it’s a great honor to be here. The next song is for You.
12. The Perfect Drug
13. Hurt / Something I Can Never Have / Right Where It Belongs / Lights In The Sky
14. La Mer
15. The Frail w. The Wretched / Into The Void / Dead Souls
16. # Rant about politics
17. Closer w. The Only Time / All Time Low / Get Down Make Love
18. Deep / Reptile / Please w. Appendage
19. Copy Of A / Came Back Haunted
20. Satellite / God Given / Discipline
21. We’re In This Together / Somewhat Damaged
22. # Band introduction and „we’ve got some more”
23. Sunspots
24. Terrible Lie
25. The Hand That Feeds
26. Head Like A Hole
~~~~~~~~~ Encore
27. Beside You In Time / The Day The Whole World Went Away / All The Love In The World
28. Just Like You Imagined / Mr. Self Destruct
29. The Fragile
30. Even Deeper / While I’m Still Here / The Great Below
31. Leaving Hope
32. Zero-Sum / In This Twilight / I’m Looking Forward To Joining You Finally w. (With Decay)
~~~~~~~~ Encore 2 on those rare, rainy days, when Trent just doesn’t give a fuck
33. Everything
34. Hot Dog (Limp Bizkit Cover)
35. Sex Dwarf
36. #Tapeworm cover
37. Kinda I Want To

[misternegative]

Home
Copy Of A
1,000,000
Came Back Haunted
March Of The Pigs
Piggy (preferably Ghosts version)
The Frail / The Wretched
Burn
Gave Up
Closer
All Time Low
The Warning
Find My Way
What If We Could?
Help Me I Am In Hell
The Mark Has Been Made
The Way Out Is Through
Into The Void
Satellite
Terrible Lie
Wish
The Big Come Down
31 Ghosts IV
The Hand That Feeds
Survivalism
The Perfect Drug
The Downward Spiral
Hurt
Head Like A Hole

ENCORE:
Somewhat Damaged
I Do Not Want This
The Good Soldier
Beside You In Time
And All That Could Have Been
In This Twilight (with Zero-Sum outro)

PHM: 2 / B: 3 / TDS: 6 / TF: 7 / WT: 3 / YZ: 4 / GI-IV: 1 / TS: 1 / HM: 5 / MISC: 4

In my dreams, I know. But it's perfect; all the normal live staples, and several surprises as well. Although it probably needs a bit of tweaking to shorten the setlist, as 30+ songs a night would be death.

[AgentofChaos]

Given that it's a confirmed 4 piece, and the direction is more YZ/Fragile and eletronic in nature.. here is a setlist I'd love to see on this tour.

1. Tetsuo the Bullet Man (starts off with Ally on stage knob twisting. TR slowly revealed in the fog as the piano starts just after the 1 minute mark. At the 1:35ish mark when the buzzing starts Robin swiftly enters from stage right. An epic drone session to set the tone for the evening)
2. Terrible Lie
3. Ruiner
4. The Becoming
5. Head Down
6. The Fragile
7. Hurt
8. Hyperpower!
9. Me, I'm Not
10. Copy of A
11. The Great Destroyer
12. The Four of Us are Dying
13. Mr. Self Destruct
14. Sunspots
15. The Line Begins to Blur
16. Beside You in Time
17. You Know What You Are
18. Where is Everybody?
19. Satellite
20. Just Like You Imagined
21. In Two
22. The Mark Has Been Made
23. Eraser
24. Wish
25. Head Like A Hole
26. Ripe (With Decay)
-

27. The New Flesh into The Day The World Went Away
28. Looking Forward to Joining You, Finally
29. Underneath It All/27 Ghosts Jam Session
30. La Mer
31. We're in this Together
32. Zero Sum

[Volband]

Would you REALLY let TFOUAD (now that's an acronym I've never used before, haha) take up a space, even if it's only contested by instrumental songs?

[Inkë]

(bonus : a song from HTDA featuring Mariqueen but with NIN band)

My wish was granted. :)

[Throw_it_away9]

TR, Ilan, Robin, Alessandro, Jeordie

Now I'm Nothing/Terrible Lie
The Line Begins to Blur
All Time Low
Pinion
Wish
Last
Help Me I'm in Hell
Happiness in Slavery
Gave Up
~Curtain/Projector Cue~
[TR: Hoped you guys liked that]
Eraser
Right Where it Belongs
La Mer/The Great Below
Complication
Eraser (Polite)
And All That Could Have Been
Beside You in Time [~where TR 'breaks' the curtain/projector a la Halo 22~]
March of the Pigs [enter Chris Vrenna on drums, Ilan to guitar]
Closer to God
[TR: This song is about, fucking]
The Only Time
[TR: Chris Vrenna, everyone! CV bows out, Ilan retakes drums]
Satellite
My Violent Heart
A Violet Fluid
~Curtain/Projector Cue~
The Eater of Dreams
Non-Entity
Ghosts 31
In Two
The Frail/The Wretched
We're in this Together
The Perfect Drug
-Encore
Just like You Imagined [Mike Garson on piano]
The Day the World Went Away [crazy piano-y version that's very intense]
Get Down, Make Love [MG exits, enter Danny Lohner on guitar]
Somewhat Damaged [DL exits @ the end]
The Loop Closes [enter Atticus & Mariqueen, rest of band leaves but Alessandro]
How Long?
A Drowning
-Encore 2
Me, I'm Not [Band intro @ the end, all performers come out and stay on, Chris & Ilan double drum kits]
The Warning [TR & M singing]
Metal [enter Gary Numan]
The Collector [enter Dave Grohl on drums, Ilan to keyboard/guitar/etc.]
Head Like a Hole
Down in It [M singing something Great Gig in the Sky-y a la Tension backup, with Black Noise/The Great Destroyer outro]

[SM Rollinger]

Well ive been thinking about this for awhile, so i dug into my live NIN collection, opened up audacity and made a setlist that i could actually listen to! I had to set a narrow focus for this because if I put together my "dream" NIN setlist it would be 4+ hours long, so I chose only SBD or near SBD quality sources. I wanted to originally used Now Im Nothing/Terrible Lie as the opener, but I couldnt find a good enough source, and the version of Copy of A is a matrix I made of mine and JBs tape of the St. Paul Tension show. Dint turn out too bad for my first attempt at something like that! Its a little odd hearing conversations you remember, and then people you have never heard before talking! Anyways, I went with the old NIN show format, explosive intro, slows down tempo wise before it picks up again. Real high energy song before the middle "quiet" section, and then back to some more mid paced stuff before the last tracks. Then of course a classic encore. If you really want to hear my mix, pm me but i wont post links here cuz I used official audio sources, along with some creative editing/mixing on some of these tracks. (which I do like doing this stuff, kinda like making Mix Tapes for your friends back in the day. I dint have a CD burner till like 02, lol)

show starts old school like with the drop curtian in front of the stage
01 Pinion
02 Terrible Lie
03 Sin
04 Letting You
05 Head Down
06 The Line Begins To Blur
07 Burn
08 Help Me I Am In Hell
09 Happiness In Slavery (did you expect me not to include this? ;) )
cue the drop curtian and frontal projection
10 La Mer
11 The Great Below
12 Hand Covers Bruise
13 Beside You In Time
ok back to normal lighting
14 Witha Teetha
15 Ruiner
16 The Becoming
17 I Do Not Want This
Trent does the band intro at this point (I used a Wave Goodbye era one)
18 Sanctified '95
19 Down In It
20 Copy of a
Encore Break (yes i added in some crowd noise for contunitity sake)
switches over to big mono screen behind the band, ala Tension or LITS
21 Right Where It Belongs
22 The Warning
23 Vessel
"thank you goodnight woooooooo!!"

[Tiger_Stealth]

How about a set-list dedicated to deeper cuts are rarely-played songs?

(Now I'm Nothing)
Mr. Self Destruct
Last
The Collector
Heresy
No, You Don't

The Becoming
The Fragile
The Good Soldier
Kinda I Want To
Head Down
Sunspots
I Do Not Want This
We're In This Together
Happiness In Slavery
A Warm Place
In This Twilight
And All That Could Have Been

The Way Out Is Through
Burning Bright (Field On Fire)
Everything
Meet Your Master
I Would For You
Ruiner
Ringfinger
Over & Out

[ghostaustin]

My violent heart
March of the pigs
Heresy
Last

We're in this together
She's gone away
Vessel

Down in it
Wish
Shit mirror
Ahead of ourselves
Driver down
God break down the door

What if we could
Me, im not
Closer

The line begins to blur
Beside you in time
Right where it belongs (v2)

Encore:
The frail
Metal
Somewhat Damaged
The perfect drug
Into the void
Head like a hole


I wonder if My Violent Heart live was ever actually in the cards

[Erneuert]

My violent heart
March of the pigs
Heresy
Last

We're in this together
She's gone away
Vessel

Down in it
Wish
Shit mirror
Ahead of ourselves
Driver down
God break down the door

What if we could
Me, im not
Closer

The line begins to blur
Beside you in time
Right where it belongs (v2)

Encore:
The frail
Metal
Somewhat Damaged
The perfect drug
Into the void
Head like a hole


I wonder if My Violent Heart live was ever actually in the cards

Since Meet Your Master was done, I don’t see why My Violent Heart couldn’t be. They have a similar groove.

[Erneuert]

How about a set-list dedicated to deeper cuts are rarely-played songs?

(Now I'm Nothing)
Mr. Self Destruct
Last
The Collector
Heresy
No, You Don't

The Becoming
The Fragile
The Good Soldier
Kinda I Want To
Head Down
Sunspots
I Do Not Want This
We're In This Together
Happiness In Slavery
A Warm Place
In This Twilight
And All That Could Have Been

The Way Out Is Through
Burning Bright (Field On Fire)
Everything
Meet Your Master
I Would For You
Ruiner
Ringfinger
Over & Out

Add Please and 10 Miles High.

[ryanmcfly]

How the West was Really Won (played over the PA like The Fireman)
1. Somewhat Damaged
2. Mr Self Destruct
3. Last
4. Sin
5. Terrible Lie
6. Me, I’m Not
7. This isn’t the Place
8. Heresy
9. Sunspots
10. The Background World
11. Find My Way
12. Right Where it Belongs
13. you made it feel like (home)
14. Eraser
15. Wish
16. The Big Come Down
17. The Line Begins to Blur
18. Various Methods of Escape
19. Ruiner
20. Down in it
21. Head like a Hole
—Encore break—
22. Help me I am in hell
23. Happiness in Slavery
24. And all that could Have Been
25. Hurt
26. In this twilight (zero-sum outro)

[Tiger_Stealth]

ASSAULT/AGGRESSION SETLIST:

Branches/Bones
Wish
Heresy
Ahead Of Ourselves
Terrible Lie
Less Than
Mr. Self Destruct
Last
Not Anymore
March Of The Pigs
Happiness In Slavery
Ruiner
God Break Down The Door
Burn
Sin
The Becoming
Gave Up
Burning Bright (Field On Fire)
Shit Mirror
Head Like A Hole