SPECIAL THANKS TO frankieteardrop FOR UPDATING THE LIST

-----------------------------
HAVE NEVER BEEN PLAYED
-----------------------------

Purest Feeling

A Warm Place debuted at Webster Hall, New York 8/23/2009
Memorabilia [Soft Cell]
March of the Fuckheads

Videodrones; Questions
The Perfect Drug
Driver Down

Where Is Everybody?
I'm Looking Forward To Joining You Finally
10 Miles High
Appendage
Underneath it All
Ripe/Ripe (With Decay)

The Great Collapse
And All That Could Have Been
The Persistence of Loss
Leaving Hope

All the Love in the World (played at rehearsals)
Sunspots (played in sound check at the Edmonton, AB show in Nov. 2005 and at rehearsals)
My Violent Heart
Zero-Sum (piano outro used during Lights in the Sky Tour)

GHOSTS:
2-4
7
9-13
15
16
18
20
22-24
26, 27, 30
33-38

The Four of us are Dying
Demon Seed

-----------------------------------------------
HAVE BEEN SAMPLED, BUT NOT PLAYED
-----------------------------------------------

999,999 (sampled as intro to LITS tour)

Pinion (sampled often as an intro)

Pilgrimage (sampled as an intro in 2006/2007)

The New Flesh (sampled as an intro in 99/00 and sporadically in 2006/2007, and on at least one occasion (1/14/00 Yokohama), Trent sang part of the song's lyrics.)

Another Version of the Truth (sampled briefly during Performance 2007)

Corona Radiata (sampled during LITS tour, as well as in a mashup on the South American leg along with The Greater Good. )

-----------------------------------------------
THE FOLLOWING SONGS DEBUTED/RESURFACED IN 2009
-----------------------------------------------

Now I’m Nothing [5/9/09] (first time played since Lollapalooza)

Physical (You’re So) [Adam and the Ants] [5/9/09] (first time played since TDS Tour)

Heresy [5/8/09] (first time played in US since TDS Tour)

The Becoming [5/8/2009] (first time played in the US since Outside Tour)

I Do Not Want This [5/9/09] (first time played since TDS Tour)

The Downward Spiral [2/17/09] (first time played since TDS Tour)

Piggy (Nothing Can Stop Me Now) [5/8/09] (first time played since Outside Tour)

I'm Afraid of Americans [David Bowie] [5/8/2009]

The Fragile [2/17/09] (first time album version has appeared since Fragility Tour)

The Way Out Is Through [5/8/09] (first time played since Fragility 1.0)

Non-Entity [2/17/09] (first time played since WT Summer Tour)

Gone, Still [5/8/09]

Metal [Gary Numan] [5/8/2009]

Right Where It Belongs [5/8/09] (first time played since WT Winter Tour)

Not So Pretty Now [5/12/09] (first time played since WT Fall Tour)

Banged and Blown Through [5/10/09] (performed both with and without Saul Williams)

Lights In The Sky [5/9/2009]

-----------------------------------------------
THE FOLLOWING SONGS DEBUTED/RESURFACED IN 2008
-----------------------------------------------

Vessel [07/28/08]

The Warning [07/25/08]

God Given [07/25/08]

Meet Your Master[07/29/08]

The Greater Good [07/26/08]

In This Twilight [07/26/08]

GHOSTS:
1 [07/26/08]
5 [07/28/08]
6 [07/28/08]
8 [8/25/08]
14 [08/15/08]
17 [07/29/08]
19 [07/26/08]
21 [07/29/08]
25 [07/26/08]
28 [08/13/08]
29 [08/10/08]
31 [07/25/08]
32 [08/12/08]

999,999 [07/25/08]

1,000,000 [07/25/08]

Letting You [07/25/08]

Discipline [07/25/08]

Echoplex [07/25/08]

Head Down [07/25/08]


-----------------------------------------------
THE FOLLOWING SONGS DEBUTED/RESURFACED IN 2007
-----------------------------------------------

Last [2/10/07]

Heresy [2/14/07] (first time played since TDS Tour)

Ruiner [2/11/07] (first time played since TDS Tour)

The Becoming [2/14/07] (first time played since the Outside Tour)

We're In This Together [2/11/07]

The Fragile [2/12/07] (Still-inspired version)

HYPERPOWER! [5/7/07]

The Beginning of the End [2/19/07]

Survivalism [3/8/07]

The Good Soldier [5/9/07]

Me, I'm Not [5/9/07]

Capital G [5/13/07]

The Great Destroyer [8/1/07]


----------

NOTE: Four tracks from Ghosts were played at the 7/19/08 Secret Show in LA. No solid confirmation on which four is currently available, but speculation says it was 1, 6 or 8, 31, and a fourth unknown.

NOTE: Nothing from Fixed, Things Falling Apart, or other remix "singles" has been played, other than the list of non-LP songs below.

ADDENDUM: Samples from the Happiness in Slavery remix on Fixed were featured in the Pukkelpop 2007 performance of The Great Destroyer.

NOTE: A Warm Place has NEVER been played live has only been played once on 8/23/2009, despite some earlier bootlegs having it listed. For example, "Nails in My Head" from New Year's 1995 in Detroit has A Warm Place listed but the track is actually The Downward Spiral (without vocals).

--------------------------------------------------------
The following non-LP songs have been played live
--------------------------------------------------------

Maybe Just Once

Now I’m Nothing

Get Down, Make Love

Closer to God

Piggy (Nothing Can Stop Me Now)

Dead Souls

Burn

Deep

Not So Pretty Now

Non-Entity

Metal

Adrift and at Peace

Gone, Still

-------------------------------------------------------
The following covers have been played live
-------------------------------------------------------

Sex Dwarf [Soft Cell]

Physical (You’re So) [Adam and the Ants] (NIN only AND NIN with Adam Ant and Marco Perroni)

Get Down, Make Love [Queen]

Dead Souls [Joy Division]

Subterraneans [David Bowie] (NIN with David Bowie)

Scary Monsters [David Bowie] (NIN with David Bowie)

Hallo Spaceboy [David Bowie] (NIN with David Bowie)

Animal [Prick] (NIN with Kevin McMahon)

Tough [Prick] (NIN with Kevin McMahon)

R.S.V.P. [Pop Will Eat Itself] (NIN with Clint Mansell)

Wise Up, Sucker [Pop Will Eat Itself] (NIN with Clint Mansell)

Red Scab [Adam and the Ants] (NIN with Adam Ant and Marco Perroni)

Beat My Guest [Adam and the Ants] (NIN with Adam Ant and Marco Perroni)

The Beautiful People [Marilyn Manson] (NIN with Marilyn Manson)

List of Demands (NIN with Saul Williams)

African Student Movement (NIN with Saul Williams)

The Sanity Assassin (Trent Reznor and Peter Murphy)

Dreams [TV on the Radio] (Trent Reznor, Peter Murphy, and TV on the Radio)

Bela Lugosi’s Dead [Bauhaus] (Trent Reznor, Peter Murphy, and TV On the Radio)

Haunted When the Minutes Drag [Love and Rockets] (sung by Peter Murphy during reworking of “Reptile”--> Trent Reznor with Peter Murphy, Atticus Ross, and Jeordie White)

Nightclubbing [Iggy Pop] (Trent Reznor with Peter Murphy, Atticus Ross, and Jeordie White)

Warm Leatherette [The Normal] (Trent Reznor with Peter Murphy, Atticus Ross, and Jeordie White)

Strange Kind of Love [Peter Murphy] (Trent Reznor with Peter Murphy, Atticus Ross, and Jeordie White)

Twenty-Four Hours [Joy Division] (NIN with Peter Murphy)

Atmosphere [Joy Division] (NIN with Peter Murphy)

Warsaw [Joy Division] (NIN with Peter Murphy)

Final Solution [Pere Ubu] (NIN with Peter Murphy)

I'm Afraid of Americans [David Bowie]

Metal [Gary Numan]

Banged and Blown Through [Saul Williams] (NIN with and without Saul Williams)

Kick Out the Jams [MC5] (Trent Reznor with Street Sweeper Social Club)

-----------------------------------------------

one last thing...

Gunshots by Computer has frequently been played by Saul Williams.

The Becoming, That's What I Get, and Heresy have been played.

Only and Beside You in Time are being played on the current tour.

Last has never been played (which is lamentable).

Thanks for the reply-
I just noticed that Only and Beside You In Time were starting to be played.
I could have swore Last was played 1-3 times.


WHEN was That's What I Get ever played?

If KT pops up in this thread, she'll tell you that Last HAS been played, in Texas in 1995, I think. I know that Trent has said otherwise, but I suspect that KT was a lot more sober than Trent was at the time.

I have seen most of the set lists from the TDS era and I have never seen "Last" listed ever.

"A Warm Place" has never been played live.

"The Becoming" was played during the Outside tour. The live version of the song is amazing. A good quality version of this can be found on the Live Hate bootleg.

"That's What I Get" was played during Pretty Hate Machine era shows.

"The Perfect Drug" has never been played live.

"We're In This Together" has never been played live which really disturbs me.

I cant remember where it was, but I say that Last was played because once on the internet I was scrolling through hundreds of setlists from NIN tours long ago...

Last appeared just a few times. Maybe only like 2 times. Spaced 1-3 months apart.

At the State Fair Coliseum in Dallas, October 29, 1994. It was the Self-Destruct leg of The Tour That Never Ended. I've never found an "import" of this concert, but I do have a couple of friends who can corroborate.

Why isn't "All The Love In The World" one of the most played songs on this new arena tour??? That's one of the best songs on WT!!! I hope it gets played in Chicago at least.

http://www.echoingthesound.org/phpbbx/viewtopic.php?p=457453#457453

If you're right, then I would kill to get a boot of that show.

Only and Heresy I've seen. It would be GrEaT to see PD live though I've heard that the drum bits would make JDs arms fall off. Thats line has been hella said more than a few times though.

i saw the bowie tour. the becoming live was unreal. one of the best nin live moments easily.

the setlist from the bowie tour was really good. best one i ever saw. however, on the recent with teeth tour "smaller venue" tour i got to hear "the big comedown" sooooo....that was a major highlight as well.

overall, nails have always kept the setlist pretty similar. i am pretty tired of hearing starfuckers, head like a hole, and hurt (i know i must be crazy. never understood the hype on this one.)

the day the world went away and burn never went over well live from what i have seen. most people look bored. reptile seems to bore the shit out of people half way through the song also from what i have seen.

the worst reaction i ever saw at a nails concert was when they played "even deeper" recently. people actually started to boo. i also heard a couple yell "boring".

would love to hear we're in this together, perfect drug, becoming (again), big comedown (again), all the love in the world, into the void, where is everybody?, please, and anything off of still.

hopefully i will hear deep, only, and getting smaller live on this tour.

the only band that i have seen mix up things drastically is the cure. everynight is a different setlist. and with the cure, there might be a night when not one "single" gets played which is fine. they have the most devoted fans on the planet it seems when it comes to live shows. i know i can't wait to see them AGAIN. you never know what to expect from a cure show. there is no boundary with them at all.

Yeah, I wanna' hear:
The Life You Didn't Lead
Message to No One
Not So Pretty Now (i know it's been played, but I want to hear it, dammit)
My Dead Friend (rumored work mentioned in article about Bleedthrough)

Wha?

maybe its just me, but I remember reading in an interview trent saying that AATCHB was the end of an era, and that with teeth was a new one. if thats true, why does he feel he needs to play Terrible Lie and head like a hole every night? since the fall tour, I dont think theyve played all the love in the world, collector, everyday is exactly the same, with teeth, home, getting smaller or sunspots. I mean thats half the new album! and according to Trent The band knows all the material. So whats the deal?

Heh, you didn't know that? It's more obvious in the studio version though, but I'm not going to continue on about this cuz it involves me rambling about the WHOLE TDS and the concept and the fuck else what and I don't wanna do that.



Well, I'm in no rush to see Collector and Getting Smaller: i'd say half (maybe mroe) aren't fans of those songs. But I'm sure he'll get around to it, eventually, cuz he doesn't really care about what we want (good for him though!).

: /

But keep in mind Jerome getting sick really put a dent in the road for Trent and Co. They WERE planning on doing something "different", which we may now see during the second leg of the WT Tour, which "kicks off" in January, and onward.

what about ruiner?

It was played several times in 1994.

Yeah its been played live. I have a copy somewhere. Sounds REALLY DISTURBING live. In all I was impressed with its live sound, but some parts sounded a little too "noisy".

It starts off with Trent saying, "This is a song about why you kill someone."