I don't have any particular companies to recommend. Though Matador did just deliver me the QOTSA album, in perfect shape and a day before release date. I couldn't be happier with that experience.

I think part of the reason for the mint record, though, is that the materials themselves are very high quality. I *really* wish your albums didn't use such thin material for sleeves. Corners are far-too-easily smooshed in shipping, seams split because the weight of the records is too much for the flimsy material to bear (just from them shifting during shipping), and corners tear during even careful extraction of the records from the sleeves. That QOTSA album is going to stand up to years and years of handling. Yours aren't even making it safely to our doorsteps, unfortunately.