Top 3 NIN songs from each album

[ManBurning]

Well, I thought the rank the albums was a pretty good idea and then This idea came to me.
I think ranking albums is hard, as each album has a number of amazing songs on them, as some have some not so great songs.
So I thought it would be neat to break it down by album and choose your top 3 fav. songs from each album, curious to see what songs are top choice per album.

Pertty Hate Machine:
1. SIN
2. Down In It
3. Terrible Lie

Broken:
1. Happiness in Slavery
2. Last
3. Physical

The Downward Spiral:
1. Reptile
2. The Becoming
3. Ruiner

The Fragile:
1. The Wretched
2. TDTWWA
3. The Big Comedown

[With_Teeth]:
1. Sunspots
2. All The Love in The world
3. The Line Begins To Blur

Year Zero:
1. Me, i'm not
2. Zero-sum
3. Beginning Of the end

Ghosts I-IV:
1. 28 Ghosts IV
2. 34 Ghosts IV
3. 32 Ghosts IV

The Slip:
1. Demon Seed
2. Head Down
3. Lights In The Sky

Rare/Unreleased/Other:
1. The Perfect Drug
2. Supernaught
3. Big Black Bomb

[ubermensch]

Pertty Hate Machine:
1. terrible lie
2. sin
3. hlah

Broken:
1. Happiness in Slavery
2. suck
3. wish

The Downward Spiral:
1. mr.self-destruct
2. reptile
3. the becoming

The Fragile:
1. The way out is through
2. TDTWWA
3. The great below

[With_Teeth]:
1. Sunspots
2. with teeth
3. The Line Begins To Blur

Year Zero:
1. in this twilight
2. meet your master
3. zero sum

Ghosts I-IV:
1. not really sure

The Slip:
1. demon seed
2. discipline
3. Lights In The Sky

Rare/Unreleased/Other:
1. burn
2. home
3. appendage

[BenAkenobi]

sin, down in it, sanctified

last, lelp me i am in hell, happiness in slavery

eraser, piggy, hurt

pilgrimage, into the void, where is everybody

only, right where it belongs, the collector

capital g, the warning, survivalism

12 Ghosts II, 20 Ghosts III, 33 Ghosts IV

discipline, echoplex, head down

burn, deep, flyentology

[Harry Seaward]

Pretty Hate Machine	Down In It	Sin	Ringfinger
Broken	Last	Physical	Suck
The Downward Spiral	Mr. Self Destruct	Ruiner	The Becoming
The Fragile	Somewhat Damaged	The Great Below	I'm Looking Forward To Joining You, Finally
[WITH_TEETH]	All The Love In The World	Beside You In Time	Right Where It Belongs
Year Zero	The Warning	In This Twilight	Zero Sum
The Slip	1,000,000	Discipline	Demon Seed
Rare/Unreleased/Other	Get Down, Make Love	Now I'm Nothing	Non-Entity

Fuck yeah tables!

Can't remember which Ghosts tracks are which.

[dzaver]

Pretty Hate Machine	Head Like a Hole	Only Time	Kinda I Want to
Broken	Last	Physical	Suck
The Downward Spiral	Ruiner	I Do not want this	The Becoming
The Fragile	Somewhat Damaged	The Day the world went away	The big come down
[WITH_TEETH]	All The Love In The World	Beside You In Time	Right Where It Belongs
Year Zero	The Warning	In This Twilight	Zero Sum
The Slip	1,000,000	Echoplex	Head down
Rare/Unreleased/Other	Get Down, Make Love	Now I'm Nothing	Non-Entity

stealing your table

[REPLICA]

Again with the ranking and the nin.

Pretty Hate Machine:
1. Down In It
2. That's What I Get
3. Head Like A Hole

Broken:
1. Gave Up
2. Wish
3. Help Me I am in Hell

The Downward Spiral:
1. Heresy
2. March of the Pigs
3. The Becoming

The Fragile - Left:
1. The Day The World Went Away
2. La Mer
3. Pilgrimage

The Fragile - Right:
1. Please
2. The Way Out Is Through
3. Into The Void

[With_Teeth]:
1. Beside You In Time
2. The Collector
3. Sunspots

Year Zero:
1. In This Twilight
2. Hyperpower!
3. God Given

Ghosts I-IV:
1. Ghosts 31
2. Ghosts 27
3. Ghosts 13

The Slip:
1. The Four of us are Dying
2. Lights in the Sky
3. Discipline

Rare/Unreleased/Other:
1. 10 Miles High
2. The Perfect Drug
3. Not So Pretty Now

[Vertigo]

Look at the pretty!

[joplinpicasso]

PHM
Ringfinger
HLAH
Sanctified

Broken
Gave Up
Happiness In Slavery
Wish

TDS
The Becoming
Reptile
MOTP

The Fragile
La Mer
TWOIT
Somewhat Damaged

WT
BYIT
TLBTB
Only

YZ
The Good Soldier
Survivalism
ITT

Ghosts
28 Ghosts IV
34 Ghosts IV
9 Ghosts I

The Slip
Echoplex
FOUAD
Demon Seed

Misc.
Burn
The New Flesh
Home

Love the graphs, but fuck yeah, ninbreviations!

[Patrick_Nicholas]

PHM:

Head Like A Hole
Down In It
The Only Time

Broken:

Happiness In Slavery
Wish
Last

TDS:

Heresy
Ruiner
Closer

The Fragile:

Just Like You Imagined
No, You Don't
The Wretched

With Teeth:

You Know What You Are?
The Hand That Feeds
The Line Begins To Blur

Year Zero:

The Great Destroyer
Capital G
Me, I'm Not

Ghosts:

31
24
8

The Slip:

The Four Of Us Are Dying
Discipline
Head Down

Other:

Deep
Burn
Dead Souls

[spahn]

Pretty Hate Machine:
1. Terrible Lie
2. That's What I Get
3. Sin

Broken:
1. Gave Up
2. Wish
3. Happiness In Slavery

The Downward Spiral:
1. Reptile
2. Ruiner
3. The Becoming

The Fragile - Left:
1. Somewhat Damaged
2. Just Like You Imagined
3. No, You Don't

The Fragile - Right:
1. The Big Comedown
2. Into The Void
3. Where is Everybody

[With_Teeth]:
1. Beside You In Time
2. The Collector
3. Right Where it Belongs

Year Zero:
1. Vessel
2. The Great Destroyer
3. The Warning

Ghosts I-IV:
1. Ghosts 09
2. Ghosts 19
3. Ghosts 22

The Slip:
1. Head Down
2. Letting You
3. The Four of us are Dying

Rare/Unreleased/Other:
1. The Perfect Drug (Plug)
2. Burn
3. Self Destruction, Final

[jrdsctt]

Pertty Hate Machine:
1. Something I Can Never Have
2. Terrible Lie
3. Sin

Broken:
1. Physical (You're So)
2. Last
3. Gave Up

The Downward Spiral:
1. Eraser
2. The Downward Spiral
3. Hurt

The Fragile:
1. Just Like You Imagined
2. Where Is Everybody?
3. Somewhat Damaged

[With_Teeth]:
1. Right Where It Belongs
2. Beside You In Time
3. Sunspots

Year Zero:
1. In This Twilight
2. The Great Destroyer
3. Zero-Sum

Ghosts I-IV:
1. 30 Ghosts IV
2. 13 Ghosts II
3. 28 Ghosts IV

The Slip:
1. Discipline
2. Lights In The Sky
3. Echoplex

Rare/Unreleased/Other:
1. At The Heart Of It All (Yes I know this is an Aphex Twin song)
2. Metal
3. Now I'm Nothing

[slave2thewage]

PHM:
Sin
Something I Can Never Have
Down In It

Broken:
Gave Up
Last
Wish

TDS:
A Warm Place
Reptile
Hurt

The Fragile (Left):
We're In This Together
Somewhat Damaged
The Great Below

The Fragile (Right):
Please
The Big Comedown
Starfuckers, Inc (you heard me)

With Teeth:
Sunspots
Right Where It Belongs
The Line Begins To Blur

Year Zero:
Zero-Sum
In This Twilight
Survivalism

The Slip:
Lights In The Sky
1,000,000
Demon Seed

[ManBurning]

Nice, I see alot of reoccuring songs on people's lists.
like sin, last, reptile, ruiner, becoming, the big comedown, sunspots tdtwwa, zero-sum, demon seed.

NIN fans must think alike regarding their faviourte songs.

Would be cool to have a couple hundred people respond and then do one of those neat graphics with the bars that vertigo did, with a tally of the top 3 responses from each album.

The only album that seems to be varying in selections is Ghosts. And that could be because there are 36 tracks there to choose from.

[frankie teardrop]

phm:
sanctified
ringfinger
sin

broken:
last
gave up
suck

downward spiral:
ruiner
eraser
the becoming

fragile (left):
we're in this together
just like you imagined
somewhat damaged

fragile (right):
the big comedown
please
the way out is through

with teeth:
every day is exactly the same
right where it belongs
the line begins to blur

year zero:
in this twilight
vessel
my violent heart

the slip:
demon seed
head down
corona radiata

miscellaneous:
burn
the great collapse
home

can't choose from ghosts... don't usually listen to it on a song-by-song basis. a favorite album that i can't extract anything from.

[Vertigo]

Would be cool to have a couple hundred people respond and then do one of those neat graphics with the bars that vertigo did, with a tally of the top 3 responses from each album.

I'd be up for compiling that if we reach a few pages, actually.

[triplesun]

Pretty Hate Machine:
The Only Time
Sin
Ringfinger

Broken:
Happiness in Slavery
Last
Suck

The Downward Spiral:
Mr. Self Destruct
The Becoming
Ruiner

The Fragile (Left):
The Great Below
Just Like You Imagined
Somewhat Damaged

The Fragile (Right):
I'm Looking Forward To Joining You, Finally
The Mark Has Been Made
Please

With Teeth:
Sunspots
Right Where It Belongs
The Line Begins to Blur

Year Zero:
My Violent Heart
The Great Destroyer
In This Twilight

Ghosts I-IV:
19 Ghosts III
4 Ghosts I
15 Ghosts II

The Slip:
Lights in the Sky
The Four Of Us Are Dying
Echoplex

Other:
Burn
10 Miles High
Home

[Zipfinator]

PHM
Head Like a Hole
The Only Time
Ringfinger

Broken
Suck
Happiness In Slavery
Gave Up

TDS
The Ruiner
Eraser
Reptile

The Fragile
Somewhat Damaged
The Big Comedown
Underneath It All

With Teeth
All The Love In The World
The Line Begins to Blur
Right Where It Belongs

Year Zero
Vessel
In This Twilight
Zero Sum

The Slip
Discipline
The Four of Us Are Dying
Demon Seed

Other/Unreleased
Home
Burn
Now I'm Nothing

The Social Network
A Familiar Taste
Painted Sun in Abstract
Soft Trees Break The Fall

TGWTDT
With The Flies
Great Bird of Prey
The Sound of Forgetting

[jrdsctt]

I'd be up for compiling that if we reach a few pages, actually.

Awesome, do it!

[ManBurning]

Awesome, do it!

Well, first we need the data, LOL. So we need a alot more people to participate then what we have already. Soooo your task is to get each and every member to fill this out! LOL, just kidding, we'll keep an eye on it and maybe in a few months when we have more data to work with, it would be a project worth taking on.

[somewhatdamaged]

Pertty Hate Machine:
1. Terrible Lie
2. Kinda I Want To
3. Sanctified

Broken:
1. Gave Up
2. Happiness In Slavery
3. Last

The Downward Spiral:
1. The Becoming
2. Ruiner
3. Eraser

The Fragile:
1. Somewhat Damaged
2. We're In This Together
3. The Mark Has Been Made

[With_Teeth]:
1. The Line Begins To Blur
2. With Teeth
3. Only

Year Zero:
1. The Great Destroyer
2. In This Twilight
3. The Good Soldier

Ghosts I-IV:
1. 34 Ghosts IV
2. 3 Ghosts I
3. 8 Ghosts I

The Slip:
1. Head Down
2. Lights In The Sky
3. Letting You

The Social Network
1. Intriguing Possiblities
2. Pieces Form the Whole
3. Carbon Prevails

The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo
1. A Thousand Details
2. Infiltrator
3. Great Bird of Prey

Rare/Unreleased/Other:
1. The Perfect Drug
2. Burn
3. Deep

[NemesisNZ]

PHM:
Something I Can Never Have
Terrible Lie
Sin

Broken:
Gave Up
Last
Suck

TDS:
Ruiner
Mr. Self Destruct
Heresy

The Fragile (Left):
Just Like You Imagined
The Great Below
The Fragile

The Fragile (Right):
Please
The Big Comedown
Complication

Still:
And All That Could Have Been
Leaving Hope
Adrift And At Peace

[With_Teeth]:
All The Love In The World
Right Where It Belongs
Getting Smaller

Year Zero:
The Great Destroyer
In This Twilight
Meet Your Master

Ghosts:
21 Ghosts III
35 Ghost IV
31 Ghosts IV

The Slip:
1,000,000
Discipline
Head Down

Rare/Unreleased/Other:
1. Burn
2. Metal
3. Where Is Everybody (Danny Lohner)

[Ripe(withdecay)]

Pretty Hate Machine:
1. Sanctified
2. That's What I Get
3. The Only Time

Broken:
1. Last
2. Happiness in Slavery
3. Gave Up

The Downward Spiral:
1. I Do Not Want This
2. Piggy
3. Reptile

The Fragile (Left):
1. Even Deeper
2. La Mer
3. The Fragile

The Fragile (Right):
1. Underneath It All
2. The Big Come Down
3. I'm Looking Forward to Joining You, Finally

With Teeth:
1. Sunspots
2. Getting Smaller
3. The Line Begins to Blur

Year Zero:
1. In This Twilight
2. Meet Your Master
3. The Beginning of the End

Ghosts I-IV:
1. 28 Ghosts IV
2. 1 Ghosts I
3. 5 Ghosts I

The Slip:
1. Head Down
2. Discipline
3. Lights In The Sky

Other:
1. Home
2. Now I'm Nothing
3. The New Flesh

[BRoswell]

Pretty Hate Machine: Head Like A Hole, Sin, Ringfinger
Broken: Happiness In Slavery, Gave Up, Help Me I Am In Hell
The Downward Spiral: Mr. Self Destruct, Hurt, Reptile
The Fragile: Somewhat Damaged, Just Like You Imagined, We're In This Together
Still: And All That Could Have Been, Leaving Hope, The Becoming
With Teeth: Love Is Not Enough, Beside You In Time, Right Where It Belongs
Year Zero: Vessel, Survivalism, The Great Destroyer
Ghosts: 1 Ghosts I, 28 Ghosts IV, 31 Ghosts IV
The Slip: 1,000,000, Echoplex, Letting You

Remix: Closer To God, The Day The World Went Away (Quiet), Another Version Of The Truth (Kronos Quartet & Enrique Gonzalez Müller)
Non-Album Tracks: Deep, Dead Souls, Theme For Tetsuo: The Bullet Man

The Social Network: Hand Covers Bruise, Eventually We Find Our Way, In The Hall Of The Mountain King
The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo: A Thousand Details, An Itch, Please Take Your Hand Away

[Trunkjob]

Took the table from earlier in the thread and extended it.

	1	2	3
Pretty Hate Machine	Sin	Head Like a Hole	Terrible Lie
Broken	Wish	Gave Up	Last
Fixed	Happiness in Slavery (Remixed)	Gave Up (Remixed)	Throw This Away
The Downward Spiral	Eraser	Reptile	Closer
Further Down the Spiral	At the Heart of It All	Eraser (Denial; Realization)	The Art of Self Destruction, Part One
The Fragile (Left Disc)	La Mer	The Wretched	We're In This Together
The Fragile (Right Disc)	The Big Come Down	The Way Out is Through	Into the Void
Things Falling Apart	Metal	Slipping Away	Starfuckers Inc. (Clouser Version)
Still	Leaving Hope	And All That Could Have Been	The Day the World Went Away (Still)
With Teeth	Sunspots	The Line Begins to Blur	Every Day is Exactly the Same
Year Zero	In This Twilight	Zero-Sum	Vessel
Y34RZ3R0R3M1X3D	In This Twilight (Fennesz)	The Great Destroyer (Modwheelmood)	Capital G (Epworth Phones)
Ghosts I-IV (I-II)	16 Ghosts II	13 Ghosts II	3 Ghosts I
Ghosts I-IV (III-IV)	24 Ghosts III	34 Ghosts IV	21 Ghosts III
The Slip	The Four of Us Are Dying	Letting You	Echoplex
How to Destroy Angels EP	Parasite	Fur-Lined	The Space in Between
The Social Network OST	In Motion	Intriguing Possibilities	On We March
Other Songs	Burn	The Perfect Drug	Dead Souls

[xcolour]

Pretty Hate Machine:
1. Head Like a Hole
2. Sin
3. Down in It

Broken:
1. Wish
2. Gave Up
3. Last

The Downward Spiral:
1. Ruiner
2. Mr. Self Destruct
3. Heresy

The Fragile:
1. The Big Come Down
2. We're in This Together
3. The Wretched

With Teeth:
1. The Line Begins to Blur
2. Beside You in Time
3. All the Love in the World

Year Zero:
1. The Great Destroyer
2. In This Twilight
3. Capital G

The Slip:
1. Lights in the Sky
2. Corona Radiata
3. Demon Seed

Other:
1. Burn
2. Dead Souls
3. I'm Afraid of Americans (please let me count it!!!)

Never really pay attention to individual tracks when I listen to Ghosts or the soundtracks, so I can't really pick anything out.

[Dethbryte]

Pretty Hate Machine:
1. Ringfinger
2. The Only Time
3. Kinda I Want To

Broken:
1. Last
2. Hapiness In Slavery
3. Suck

The Downward Spiral:
1. Ruiner
2. The Becoming
3. Reptile

The Fragile - Left:
1. Even Deeper
2. No, You Don't
3. We're In This Together

The Fragile - Right:
1. Please
2. The Big Come Down
3. Where Is Everybody?

[With_Teeth]:
1. With Teeth
2. The Line Begins To Blur
3. Right Where It Belongs

Year Zero:
1. Vessel
2. Meet Your Master
3. Me, I'm Not

Ghosts I-IV:
1. 31 Ghosts IV
2. 8 Ghosts I
3. 23 Ghosts III

The Slip:
1. Discipline
2. Letting You
3. Demon Seed

Rare/Unreleased/Other:
1. Theme For Tetsuo The Bullet Man
2. Not So Pretty Now
3. Deep

[gorast]

No real order for any of them.

PHM:
The Only Time, Sin, Terrible Lie

Broken:
Wish, Last, Gave Up

TDS:
Hurt, Reptile, A Warm Place

TF Left:
La Mer, The Great Below, JLYI

TF Right:
Starfuckers, Inc., The Big Come Down, The Way Out is Through

WT:
Right Where It Belongs, Only, Sunspots

YZ:
The Great Destroyer, Meet Your Master, The Good Soldier

Ghosts I-IV:
34 IV, 19 III, 21 III

TS:
Discipline, Echoplex, Lights in the Sky

Non-album:
Home, Leaving Hope, TPD

[piggy]

PHM: Something I Can Never Have, Head Like A Hole, Sanctified
Broken: Last, Wish, Happiness In Slavery
TDS: Piggy, I Do Not Want This, Ruiner
The Fragile: We're In This Together, The Fragile, The Big Come Down
With Teeth: Love Is Not Enough, All The Love In The World, Right Where It Belongs
Year Zero: Vessel, My Violent Heart, God Given
Ghosts: 2 Ghosts I, 12 Ghosts II, 28 Ghosts IV
The Slip: The Four Of Us Are Dying, Discipline, Echoplex

[peter]

PHM: Sin, terrible lie, the only time.
Broken: Last, physical, gave up.
TDS: Eraser, ruiner, closer
Fragile: We're in this together, La Mer, Big Comedown
With Teeth: Love is not enough, beside you in time, home
Year zero: capital g, vessel, me I'm not
ghosts: (will add these, need my playlist at home, not good with the numberings)
The slip: head down

[jmtd]

PHM: Sin, Head like a Hole, Ringfinger

Broken: Last, Wish, Physical

TDS: The Becoming, Ruiner, The Downward Spiral

Fragile: We're in this together, the day the world went away, The Fragile

With Teeth: The Line Begins to Blur, The Hand That Feeds, Getting Smaller

Year zero: In This Twilight, Meet your Master, Vessel

The slip: Demon Seed, the four of us are dying, head down

Of the above I found PHM the hardest to choose.