lol
Behold the morning star
lol
Active Member
Hihihi... *rolls eyes*Originally Posted by botley
I suppose that is a fair review. Some food for thoughts for everyone.
Throbbing Member
They absolutely dismantled the entire movie. If only Disney's writing was this good.
24.24.2.2866
Yikes......
I was nobody. Nothing.
Jesus. Here we go again.
Why do the Star Wars threads get so toxic?
Didn't @Rabbit get banned last time over this type of shit?
Active Member
That guy is annoying as fuck, but he makes some good and bad arguments as well. What made this video listenable for me is that he wasn't that ignorant as he sounded to be. Ie. when criticizing the Leia scene, at least he admitted that yes, we know she is Force sensitive, and then goes on explaining why HE thinks it was still a bad way to show it.
So not sure if this is "yikes, what an idiot" or "yikes, too true", but it's a little bit of both.
Because many of us are passionate about what we like. Some random bloke listens to Hesitation Marks and he says he likes it or he doesn't like it, then moves on. Come to ETS, the primary NIN fan hub, and you have hundreds of wall of texts trying to explain why Hesitation Marks rocks or sucks. There is not much point in trying to play the role of a mediator in these cases. Like, what do you expect? People to not be overjoyous, happy, disappointed or angry? People not to argue? Imagine if the thread for Hesitation Marks would have been locked by the end of page two, with the last comment being yours: "guys, some of you liked it, some of you didn't, let's not stress about it. just move on!"
The problem is that people can't handle that nothing is sweet sunshine, and since they can't come up with arguments on their own, because all their mind contains is "well, I liked it..." (which in itself is fine), they try to torpedo the critics some other ways. "Oh, you're so troll!!!!" - said by the same people who upvoted my shit in the TFA thread when I was making arguments for the movie instead of them. But voicing my criticism and questioning the others' reasoning in TLJ is no longer acceptable by them, so they try their best to box me as a hater, nevermind the vast evidence on this very board that I'd want nothing for this trilogy but success.
But since no one is writing sensible stuff instead of them, they have to rely on the brave facepalm option and trying to drag it on a purely personal level, because me being or not being a rude person is apparently more important in a Star Wars thread, than the movie instead.
And I don't know if our beloved Rabbit got banned or not, but I fondly remember arguing with him. Re-reading his posts, he was the billpulsipher of Star Wars. Hating TFA (or any movie) is not inherently wrong, but he was way too caught up in his conservative views.
Female backing vocals? 0/10, where's my drugged out Trent?? = A Diesney movie? Where's my George Lucas who worked so hard and meticulously on the Original Trilogy, which is the best there ever was??
It's not exactly fair to bury him, because - in his own way - he did touch on some reasonable points. He just couldn't stop at "okay, explain to me how this scene makes sense", he had to go to "THIS IS ALL DISNEY FAULT, THEY ARE COMING TO OUR CHILDREN TOO!"
But here is the important thing: I'm sorry, is everybody seriously calling @Rabbita crybaby for having a perfectly valid opinion about a piece of popular culture? I didn't realize the groupthink was so strong here at ETS. - no, not my sentence, but it was liked by one of the administrators. That should suffice.
Active Member
You know, for a movie you're 6/10 about, you sure put a lot of energy and time into this here thread. And didn't you go see it numerous times either?
That's what's baffling to me in general about this movie: How enraged about A FUCKIN KIDS MOVIE made by Disney can you be, really? And why the need to rub your opinion on how bad you think it is into everyone's faces again and again? This is not fuckin Citizen Kane here, nor did it ever say it was. And it never aspired to be. Seriously, move on.
Behold the morning star
Star Wars is something more to some people. Just like Nine Inch Nails is something more to others.
Yea, in the grand schemes of things both are minuscule, but this is a internet forum and this thread is a discussion. I doubt he/she is constantly taking about the movie outside of this thread.
They are just opinions.
Last edited by Conan The Barbarian; 12-29-2017 at 06:46 AM.
Active Member
Yeah, the 3rd viewing is always delayed by some bullshit. The next "3rd viewing" supposed to happen tomorrow, but I believe it when it happens.
Don't call it a kids movie, please. That is an unnecessary oversimplification that serves no purpose other than trying to create some sort of immunity, because if Dora the Explorer were to be criticized by adults for being too childish, that wouldi ndeed be... um, embarassing. The Force Awakens has a scene in its first 10 minutes where Kylo orders his men to slaughter innocent people. Anakin murders children. Rose gives a social commentary in TLJ which kids can not even understand. People are being dismembered all over the series. Shall I go on, or can we agree that there's a difference between a kids movie (like Spy Kids) and Star Wars?
In the TFA thread I explained like one million times to people why the Finns vs Kylo and the Rey vs Kylo scenes made sense. Was that a useful way to spend my time? Probably not, but it was important to me, because it grinded my gears how a good movie is being smashed for something it did absolutely right - instead of the things it didn't, because it wasn't flawless. In TLJ, I am open to discuss great and terrible things alike. There are things I feel being blown up for no reason at all (Luke and the milk, Yoda, Leia, Poe, etc.) and there are things which are ignored when they should not be (direct opposition to the ideas of TFA, cheap shock value instead of meaningful character developement, etc.). Is it a useful way to spend my time? Probably not, but there are other people, like me, who like to waste hours by sharing and discussing their and others' ideas, and this is what these platforms are for, right?
"Move on" sounds rather ignorant, when you put it into context. Ever heard people, even friends arguing after they lost in a video game, or even during those games? CS, CoD, LoL, DOTA, etc. A bunch of grown up people being all worked up over lines of codes. They are obviously invested into it, so telling them to move on helps absolutely no one. Why out of all places it is an internet board, where I feel the need to explain that I have a geek side that is invested in SW?
Once again, on a board (being a cult to a person who makes music we like) with full of people whose thinking about life is mostly liberal, some people have a very hard time understanding how someone can be invested in something that's not even real.
Exactly! Maybe I come across as some neckbeard dude, who walks around in his "Han Shot First" T-shirt and not being invited anywhere, because during every social event, I climb atop of a table and rant about TLJ, but that's couldn't be farther from the turth, and no offense to people with those T-shirts.
I still urge every friend of mine who hadn't seen it to go watch it at least once.
Active Member
This thread sucks.
God is an American
Are you surprised?
Active Member
When botley brings out the irony about a hive mind, then keeps on being the yes-man of this thread. Tasty.
God is an American
Do you really need to keep doing this? Get some self-awareness, man.
Active Member
There was ONE airing in ONE cinema where I could book proper seats for tomorrow (TLJ, obv.) in the capital fucking city. I hoped to finally watch a movie in IMAX, but in the end I'm glad I could even find proper seats after all. Zzz.
What did you post in this thread so far? Ooh, that's right...Keep talking about self-awareness, while you are acting as a lackey to your friend and trying to flamebait me. Well, not exactly trying, as you more or less succeed, but still. Quite sad.
Throbbing Member
matches the movie.
lest we forget
Last edited by Sallos; 12-29-2017 at 09:40 AM.
Active Member
only b/c @Volband is allowed to bloviate like a sociopath in it.
Active Member
I don't have the power to stop any of you from saying anything you want to about the movie. You yourself decided that you want to talk about me, because I am apparently more important, than Star Wars. As flattering as it is, currently we have 8 off-topic comments on this page from people complaining about comments without depth.
How about if instead of whining and crying, you either get a grip or take your personal displeasures with me to PMs? Absolutely ridiculous how you blew this up, then blamed it on me.
(and yes, i am aware that I am just as childish as you are by entertaining this notion of "oh mah gawd, I literally can't post in this thread because of big bad Volband!! for totes, guys!"; no excuse for that)
Throbbing Member
Currently listening to this,
..while frantically reading through the posts in this thread. Absolutely riveting stuff.
Back to the Snoke origins theories, some theorists have been pointing to a connection with the temple mosaic of the first jedi.
Could they be on to something?
Administrator
It's fucking Star Wars.
I'm shutting this thread down until I've had a chance to peruse it and hand out judgments. Be nice to each other until then.
Administrator
Play nice and quit smacking your laser swords at every turn you get.
Thanks.
Active Member
Finally watched it again. It was much more enjoyable than the 2nd watch, so waiting a few weeks turned out to be beneficial. The good thing in n+1 watches is that you see things you might otherwise miss, because I kept watching what happened in the background more this time.
- Rey's nails are beautifully cut.
- During the Finn vs Phasma fight, BB-8 is wrecking havoc in the background with the stolen AT-ST.
- In the Rey vs. Kylo scene it's very cool how those fiery things keep falling down.
- I read on Facebook that someone said the choreography during the throne room fight was shit. I watched how the guards try to outnumber them and if there's any Bud Spencer-like "I'm gonna wait for my turn to get hit" moments. Maybe there is, but nothing stood out for me. Also, I'd like to see a movie that does the many vs 1 fight in a super realistic way.
- Porgs are flying around the island in (almost) every shot. I didn't even know they can fly properly.
- I still don't know if those were A-wings in the first space fight scene but I am too lazy to google it.
Of course, with the new good things you can see new bad things as well.
- I still don't get the way they've done Yoda. A CGI puppet was like the only way they could piss off just about everyone and the madmen did it. He looks out of place.
- In that scene where Rey is swinging around with the lightsaber, Luke could have given her some instruction before/while/after crying dramatically. I can do without a full-fledged training, but is it really that hard to use some mumbo-jambo like "with more finesse! don't aim to destroy? faster!" etc.? That whole scene would've been reaaallyyy good. This way it was just - again - nice cinematography with those shots.
- The lack of logical errors (ie. Holdo not revealing her plan) is especially surprising for a movie that is so meta with almost everything else. A good part of the movie consists of people explaining things to the audience. Ie. "There must be another way out.... WAIT, THE ARCTIC FOXES!!!!"
- Was it just me who was bothered by Poe when he said Luke wants to win time for them to escape? That scene felt very unnatural and rushed in order to advance the plot. What if Luke went out to destroy everything and expected some help? If it was said by Leia, it would've been believable at least.
Miscellaneous:
- There is a scene at the beginning right after Poe switches back the flight mode of his X-wing and blasts a turret. He says something (to BB-8 I believe) but it is not translated to Hungarian. The funny thing is, that in the Hungarian trailer, that very scene is there and it's translated there.
- In our dubbed version, we never get a name for DJ.
- The reaction to jokes. One audience laughed their ass off at the ironing space shuttle-bait, this one did not have anyone laugh, The first two audiences never laughed at C-3PO's joke, most noticeably on his last one, when he finishes his sentence after Poe old him to shut it. This audience had a few members to actually giggle at his quirkiness. I am onto something, but not sure what exactly.
At least this time everyone shut the fuck up during the warp jump scene.
Active Member
But he wasn't CGI. They used a real puppet again. They made a replica of the original puppet, even.
Active Member
Don't ruin his hatefest!
Active Member
Well, the verdict is in folks. TLJ was a massive flop. There's unlikely to be another Star Wars movie ever again.
http://www.looper.com/102789/star-wa...ampaign=markfb
Member
Active Member
Okay, I was wrong. But why is he still ugly and out of place? You guys jump on the fact that I thought it was bad CGI, and feel vindicated when it turns out it was just bad puppeteering.
Since there are people who understand movie's income more than I am, I'd just quote someone from reddit:
"The numbers are huge but the performance is still subpar. Final box office for TLJ is gonna be somewhere around 650, which means it won't even reach x3 of it's 220 million domestic opening. It's subpar for Christmas release date, and it has weaker box office legs than TFA(x3.7) and Rogue One(x3.45)"
So let me translate what you guys are upvoting currently: "TLJ is the weakest Star Wars release by Disney, even being outperformed by a spin-off movie, but it made much more than Beauty and the Beast, so there is really no other evidence needed that this is - without a doubt - an amazing SW movie."
It's very sad when the only way this movie can be defended is by either hyperboles or saying things out of context.
Active Member
TFA was the first SW movie in ten years, and featured most of the original cast. TLJ is now the third SW movie in three years, so you can expect a slight drop-off. A billion in two weeks, yeah, a real flop.
House Always Wins
The puppet was ugly and almost matched the same look as the one in The Phantom Menace.
Active Member
No, it didn't. You can go ahead and think that it was ugly – that's your opinion, but it looked nothing like that version from TPM.The puppet was ugly and almost matched the same look as the one in The Phantom Menace.
House Always Wins
I said almost. I didn't say it was. Neither TLJ or TPM puppets matched the original trilogy's. Only point I was making.
Posting Permissions
